I'm an absolute softie for a guy that can make me laugh, I genuinely think someone could laugh me in to bed. I guess I'm sort of attractive to some people and my friends used to make jokes that my ex wasn't the best looking guy, which on the outside was true. But that didn't really bother me, in fact in a weird way I found it comforting that I was better looking than him! And because he had such a good sense of humour, we'd often joke that he could never cheat on me because it'd be unlikely he'd get someone more attractive. That might sound weird to some people but even though he had his body hang ups, he could joke about it. I think it's important not to take yourself too seriously, girls want to spend time with someone thats fun! Who wants to sit in nandos listening to some muscly tanned guy brag about his gym routine (the most boring hour of my life.) I know it might seem like it but not every female is looking for an adonis.
Whilst I'm probably not as in to looks as other people, a no go for me is a guy that's shorter than I am, or even just slightly taller than me. I like to snuggle into someones chest without whacking my head on their chin and I think it's instinct for some woman to want to feel safe and protected by someone they're in a relationship/seeing, maybe I'm just old school in that sense.