I've finished now (three A*s); I was the first year to do the new AQA course. I didn't like it. In all three subjects, but especially physics, it didn't feel enough like science. Yes, make subjects relevant, but don't take out all the value. In the official textbook there was actually an activity consisting of writing a poem, or a letter to your MP. Call me old-fashioned, but that's not science!
Everything was wildly politicised, at the expense of rigour and knowledge. Sure, be aware of the debate around renewable energy, but if you're studying a science the focus should be on the theories and facts, not on the opinions.
In addition, there were issues with the way exams tended to be marked - far too many questions had many possible answers, only one of which was rewarded by the mark scheme.
Does that help?