Doctor Who - Discussion Thread I

How can Moffat kill off the Doctor, as Matt Smith, in the first ****ing five minutes?! That's basicalyl telling everyone "this is the last doctor. ****ing bite me." Well **** him! He's a dick. I want the other guy back as the main writer.

TELL MEEE. Please.

Time can be rewritten

Time can be rewritten

How can Moffat kill off the Doctor, as Matt Smith, in the first ****ing five minutes?! That's basicalyl telling everyone "this is the last doctor. ****ing bite me." Well **** him! He's a dick. I want the other guy back as the main writer.

Hmm, but surely River would remember beforehand that she had made that phone call etc.

But it would be interesting if it is, it would certainly link in with the whole travelling in opposite directions stuff.

DOCTOR,
Y U NO LIVE FOREVER AND EVER?

I doubt it will, not in the sense of changing the opening scene because that would render the entire series meaningless.

I'm guessing there will be some other explanation. Some back up regeneration or some way to restore him.

River said that this couldn't though!

The ship from The Lodger. I mean really.

Oh and the little girl in the spaceship. I can't work out whether she's really just like generated image from The Lodger but if she was then she wouldn't have had the powers she had in the beginning so that's crossed out. I'm guessing it's something like being stuck in the suit so you need to kill someone in other to escape? But does the ship in The Lodger/today's episode really belong to the Silents/Silence or are they just guarding it for someone else?

Also I figured out that Amy was pregnant ages ago.

But then there's the fact that River also felt sick suddenly after seeing The Silents/Silence and forgetting. Hmm?

Well indeed, think of DoctorDonna 'hand' sort of backup.

But if they made a storyline specifically to rewrite that piece of history, then it wouldn't really be a cop-out.

Hmm, true , she would have remembered the worst day for her is when he doesn't remember her- which is in Silence in the library
He has to live forever and ever :fuhrer: anyway, I bet he will they can't kill the doctor!!!!

Hmm, true , she would have remembered the worst day for her is when he doesn't remember her- which is in Silence in the library
He has to live forever and ever :fuhrer: anyway, I bet he will they can't kill the doctor!!!!

I'm not so sure. Like with the Coat Doctor, they would have to show that entire scene again, played it but this time reveal who was under the visor. And to do that, they would have to replay it exactly.

Something tells me Moffat would never make it as obvious as that, straightaway considering River said "I killed a good man" and you don't find out who until later on.

Maybe you get pregnant after looking at them

I noticed that too, but that ship was destroyed in that episode. The fact that it was even there was an illusion...to disguise the fact that it was actually there. This one had a different colour scheme to it, but they're definitely related!

God knows how you figured out about Amy. I was clueless!