This discussion is now closed.
Check out other Related discussions
- Oxford or Cambridge med?
- Year 10 work experience
- placement problems
- Medicine or something else?
- Official UEA Offer Holders Thread for 2024 entry
- How to become a prescriber?
- Is Physican Associate a good career choice?
- Medicine or dentistry
- Year 10 medicine work experience
- Advice on medical school worth applying
- Medicine-Postgraduate
- what steps to take to become a doctor who does research
- Would it be worth it pursuing a postgraduate degree in graduate entry medicine?
- Can I ever get into Medicine after spending my entire teens in hospitals
- Hate my Course
- British Medical degree vs Irish Medical degree
- A Level Choices
- RAF medical
- WANTED: Speakers for Medical Application Abroad
- Medicine Wiki [currently a Work In Progress]
Doctor Who - Discussion Thread II
Scroll to see replies
Original post by Ape Gone Insane
Reference to the Watergate tapes?
Yeah, a very nice one at that.
Original post by sheep_go_baa
I don't think there could be any thing more 'right' than the Doctor and River 
Original post by Aula
Hmm... there's a thought. Spoilered 'cause it uses something from the possible spoiler about River, but doesn't really give away anything.
Spoiler
That makes a lot of sense especially with (genuine spoiler about the finale but not really)
Spoiler
Actually it's not a spoiler but a speculation about an unconfirmed spoiler which isn't exactly huge but might be true. This whole spoiler thing is confusing so click at your own risk.
I posted this in the other thread but this seems to have more activity so i thought I would see what people think here. I feel it is unlikely that this would be so as it doesn't seem the shows style, but then again the way the show is going every episode surprises me. Although it is far fetched i feel it avoids the whole doctor/Amy having an affair problem.
Amy having an affair with the Doctor does not seem like something BBC or the Doctor would do, is it possible that the Silence used the post-hypnotic abilities to manipulate the Doctor and Amy at one point so they would have a baby but forget about it? This would explain why it would happen and why they don't remember, and Amy did say about how they had been travelling around a lot together as an explanation of why she told him not Rory. This would mean that the Silence would be able to raise their own timelord that would be able to fly their tardislike ships, without the Doctor knowing?
Amy having an affair with the Doctor does not seem like something BBC or the Doctor would do, is it possible that the Silence used the post-hypnotic abilities to manipulate the Doctor and Amy at one point so they would have a baby but forget about it? This would explain why it would happen and why they don't remember, and Amy did say about how they had been travelling around a lot together as an explanation of why she told him not Rory. This would mean that the Silence would be able to raise their own timelord that would be able to fly their tardislike ships, without the Doctor knowing?
Original post by Aula
Hmm... there's a thought. Spoilered 'cause it uses something from the possible spoiler about River, but doesn't really give away anything.
Spoiler
Which might explain Madame Kovarian through the window. She seemed to be observing the 'time-line' as such...
Does anyone want to sum up the 23 pages I missed while watching So You Think You Can Dance and Britain's Got Talent?
Original post by ??????????????????
Oh just realised what the spoiler was.
I thought of that last week lol. Maybe she:
I thought of that last week lol. Maybe she:
Spoiler
This all smells like a bad case of time paradox :trades: Which can be solved by "time can be unwritten" thing
How would she stop getting pregnant?
Original post by Sithiris
I posted this in the other thread but this seems to have more activity so i thought I would see what people think here. I feel it is unlikely that this would be so as it doesn't seem the shows style, but then again the way the show is going every episode surprises me. Although it is far fetched i feel it avoids the whole doctor/Amy having an affair problem.
Amy having an affair with the Doctor does not seem like something BBC or the Doctor would do, is it possible that the Silence used the post-hypnotic abilities to manipulate the Doctor and Amy at one point so they would have a baby but forget about it? This would explain why it would happen and why they don't remember, and Amy did say about how they had been travelling around a lot together as an explanation of why she told him not Rory. This would mean that the Silence would be able to raise their own timelord that would be able to fly their tardislike ships, without the Doctor knowing?
Amy having an affair with the Doctor does not seem like something BBC or the Doctor would do, is it possible that the Silence used the post-hypnotic abilities to manipulate the Doctor and Amy at one point so they would have a baby but forget about it? This would explain why it would happen and why they don't remember, and Amy did say about how they had been travelling around a lot together as an explanation of why she told him not Rory. This would mean that the Silence would be able to raise their own timelord that would be able to fly their tardislike ships, without the Doctor knowing?
But the Doctor always knows...
Original post by sleekchic
Spoiler
Did you notice that Roman reference in today's episode? Romans being driven out of Rome, and all things considered about the future...
Original post by hxecute
Spoiler
Spoiler
Original post by sleekchic
That makes a lot of sense especially with (genuine spoiler about the finale but not really)
Spoiler
Ooh, I'd forgotten about that, but yes, I feel that makes it even more likely.
Original post by spacepirate-James
Which might explain Madame Kovarian through the window. She seemed to be observing the 'time-line' as such...
Was she observing the time line or are they clashing/merging? I mean the Madam Kovarian scene presumably also about Amy has happened in a different timeline but for whatever reason it was drawn to that particularly moment and Amy was able to see it?
Original post by Colonel.
Could one of these timelines be a figment of Amy's imagination?
And I find it strange that the Doctor took exception to the Silents...they were not doing much wrong.
And I find it strange that the Doctor took exception to the Silents...they were not doing much wrong.
Yeah, I found that hard to believe also. What if The Silents made the Doctor do it for some reason through post hypnotic suggestion? Maybe it gave them an excuse to kill him in the future?
(edited 13 years ago)
Original post by TulipFields
This all smells like a bad case of time paradox :trades: Which can be solved by "time can be unwritten" thing
How would she stop getting pregnant?
How would she stop getting pregnant?
By getting Rory to use a condom?
Original post by spacepirate-James
Maybe only a Time Lord could pilot a Tardis?
That doesn't really seem viable. If only a Time Lord could pilot the Tardis, surely the Doctor would know that. And if he did, he'd know Riversong was a Time Lord, which he doesn't... unless, of course, he's been covering it up for some timey wimey reason.
Original post by spacepirate-James
Did anyone else get confused in the fight scene when River turned round to look at Rory and she didn't seem to forget the whole silent scene/thing?
?
?
I just looked at this scene again and I'm thinking it could be one of Moffat's subtle hints that's going to become key.
I also noticed, anyone seeing links between this and the Pandorica episodes, with the perfect prison and what not?
(edited 13 years ago)
Original post by greeneyedgirl
Does anyone want to sum up the 23 pages I missed while watching So You Think You Can Dance and Britain's Got Talent?
Lots of paradoxes.
Mainly about Amy and the little girl. Doctor death. Silence theories (I THINK THEY MAY BE GOOD)
Original post by Ape Gone Insane
Did you notice that Roman reference in today's episode? Romans being driven out of Rome, and all things considered about the future...
Glad you mentioned that:
Spoiler
Original post by Ape Gone Insane
Well it did throw back a Silent...
Probably got shone in the eye
I was worried it was going to actually do physical damage thankfully it didn't 
Original post by Aula
Hmm... there's a thought. Spoilered 'cause it uses something from the possible spoiler about River, but doesn't really give away anything.
Spoiler
Spoiler
Madame Kovarian is oddly similar to Doctor Moon from Silence in the Library. The whole sequence with CAL dreaming of a library, and Doctor Moon overseeing her...
Original post by Robbie c
Spoiler
Yeah, I thought that as well but then I thought wouldn't it be a bit weird for even a Time Lord to make sexual remarks towards his daughter, and vice versa?
Related discussions
- Oxford or Cambridge med?
- Year 10 work experience
- placement problems
- Medicine or something else?
- Official UEA Offer Holders Thread for 2024 entry
- How to become a prescriber?
- Is Physican Associate a good career choice?
- Medicine or dentistry
- Year 10 medicine work experience
- Advice on medical school worth applying
- Medicine-Postgraduate
- what steps to take to become a doctor who does research
- Would it be worth it pursuing a postgraduate degree in graduate entry medicine?
- Can I ever get into Medicine after spending my entire teens in hospitals
- Hate my Course
- British Medical degree vs Irish Medical degree
- A Level Choices
- RAF medical
- WANTED: Speakers for Medical Application Abroad
- Medicine Wiki [currently a Work In Progress]
Latest
Trending
Last reply 1 month ago
Favourite anime of all time - remove 4 and add 4 from the last posterTV shows
39
Trending
Last reply 1 month ago
Favourite anime of all time - remove 4 and add 4 from the last posterTV shows
39
