Doctor Who - Discussion Thread II

Uh, why is Donna there?

EDIT: Or should it be why is Rose and other Doctor there? Or what are Doctor and Donna doing there

it was after the daleks tried to wipe out the whole of reality, rose had come back to try and warn them all what would happen as it was happened sooner in the dimension she had gone to live in for some reason. Donna was his companion at the time, the doctor by rose is the 'human' doctor that got created when david tennant healed by regeneration but didnt change form as he channeled the energy into the hand he had chopped off when he was first creared. Then donna touched the hand and it made her part time lord in the brain and the new 'human' doctor was grown. This scene is from when rose and the 'human' doctor go back to the world she has been living i think

A random thought that may or may not have been mentioned previously. What if the life support wasn't to keep her alive, but was some kind of prison to stop her regenerating?

The little girl at the end of the DotM?

1) Keeping her alive would stop her regenerating.
2) If it was for that purpose, why does it take her 6 months to finally regenerate?

The little girl at the end of the DotM?

1) Keeping her alive would stop her regenerating.
2) If it was for that purpose, why does it take her 6 months to finally regenerate?

Well, the only thing I have to say about that episode is: why was the Doctor so disgusted about alien bogeys, given that:
1) He's a Doctor so he's meant to understand that bogeys are natural, and
2) It's a bit hypocritical of him, seeing as he's not exactly human himself.

XD

I salute Rory and Amy though. That's what I call true love.

Well, the only thing I have to say about that episode is: why was the Doctor so disgusted about alien bogeys, given that:
1) He's a Doctor so he's meant to understand that bogeys are natural, and
2) It's a bit hypocritical of him, seeing as he's not exactly human himself.

XD

I salute Rory and Amy though. That's what I call true love.

in addition to what boba said; its not hypocritical because they wernt time lord bogeys so they are still alien to both him and us, im sure human bogeys would be just as alien and disgusting to him

ah I edited my post but you beat me to it

They are grown. But this is Doctor Who. Anything goes That's a valid point. Forgot about them being grown.

On a related note, you should also give this a watch. It got cut:

What do you think of Amy's pregnancy after that episode? Also Madame Kovarian's calm down or something along those lines comment.

It seemed the scan was still in progress but for whatever reason it was taking so long.

Oh, and how did it get on the wiki in the first place?

Fans pick up the names from the glimpses at the script. Leaks and stuff.


Good point about the repressed or forgotten memories. Another interesting piece of dialogue was the Doctor's constant hints.

In Day of the Moon he chooses to go off on an adventure "You only live once" and in this episode he said "We all have to go some time". He knows something.

The Doctor is slightly psychic isn't he? So he might have alreayd seen it in their minds?

I think he was scanning her again if I am honest.

IMDB has given so much away

Take IMDB with a pinch of salt.

But why? At the end of Day of the Moon, we first thought that the scan was completed and she was pregnant and not pregnant. Then we concluded that actually the scan was in progress but we didn't get to see the result, the Doctor did. So if the Doctor did, why did he need to scan her again?

I think the pregnancy/Madame Kovarian might be resolved in episode 7. Well not resolved but we'll find out more about them in episode 7.