Do we need a British Islam? (BBC Big Questions)

The law would dfine them as civically British. I am not talking about civic nationallity

What are you talking about then?

Are you actually that thick?

We need a return to old Britain that was full of British people instead of ethnically destroying it and calling it diversity.

We need a return to old Britain that was full of British people instead of ethnically destroying it and calling it diversity.

It is what it is.

You can call me a hater but most non-White people who come here are shocked at what they see.

The guy in the blue sweater is a complete moron, he wants to believe Islam is peaceful so he wants to change Islam to something which isn't Islamic.

Religion is what you make out of it. Without its believers, it doesn't exist.

So, people can develop their own interpretation of Islam, just like they can develop their interpretation of Christianity, Buddhism etc : religions are not copy-righted, and you can put on your religion any label you want

Yes, people will attack you and criticise you : but, what do you care ? it's between you and your "God"

As a non-white person who came here, how so?

What do you mean they are shocked by what they say? Shocked about what? Please elaborate further.

That's such a Protestant thing to say.

We need a return to old Britain that was full of British people.

it started with the Romans, and from then on it went downhill fast... the Saxons, the Danes, the Normans .. and now the "immigrants"... what next ?

the world is going crazy : bring back good old Neanderthal Britain. Down with homo sapiens.

Adam Deen, in that debate, also engaged in some dubious debating and general scaremongering. Yes, he brought up apostasy because it is a crime in some Muslim countries but it isn't at all relevant to Muslims in Britain today.

He could have talked about any of the issues plaguing Muslims in Britain today (drugs, gangs, prisons etc etc)


Yes, leaving one's religion should not be punishable by death but I can't support Adam Deen on this one. He came to the debate with one point, and that was of apostasy, a concept which probably is irrelevant to the 3.5 million Muslims in the UK.

the vast majority of british muslims have integrated fine in British society. its the extreme ones who go OTT and ruin things for us by giving us a dumb label.

Don't forget the Jutes and the Picts.

You don't have to be violent to be an extremist. The views held by much of this 'vast majority' are decidedly not indicative of a successful integration into British society.

the vast majority of british muslims have integrated fine in British society. its the extreme ones who go OTT and ruin things for us by giving us a dumb label.