My reaction to The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo is a rather confused one. Weirdly, I can't think of a single problem with it that didn't stem in some way or another from its irritating, one-note source material: it was well-acted, well-directed (obviously) and the soundtrack was beyond reproach. Nevertheless, while it was, I suppose, 'good', it was far from Fincher's best work.
Also saw The Rum Diary, which is largely weak. Depp can be praised for suitably toning down his interpretation of Hunter S. Thompson* from the indulgent chaos of Fear and Loathing while still staying true to the man himself, but there's little else to praise about it. Expected better.
* The "toning down" does include a car battle ending with Depp literally breathing fire, but still.