The Student Room Group

Binomial expansion

Hi guys I've found the binomial expansion of a fraction which i attached here and the whole workings but at the end I'm not sure if the binomial expansion carries on or it should be stopped?i've marked both ways by a question mark so you can see the answers and help me choose one of them.
thanks for your time
Reply 1
Original post by Alen.m
Hi guys I've found the binomial expansion of a fraction which i attached here and the whole workings but at the end I'm not sure if the binomial expansion carries on or it should be stopped?i've marked both ways by a question mark so you can see the answers and help me choose one of them.
thanks for your time


It definitely carries on. Using the ++ \cdots \, \, is good practice. In A-Level exams, you'll be asked to "expand up to the term in x^2 or x^3 or whatever" and you can give your final answer without the ellipses.
(edited 8 years ago)
Reply 2
Original post by Alen.m
Hi guys I've found the binomial expansion of a fraction which i attached here and the whole workings but at the end I'm not sure if the binomial expansion carries on or it should be stopped?i've marked both ways by a question mark so you can see the answers and help me choose one of them.
thanks for your time

Can you post what the question asks you to do?
Reply 3
Like Zacken says, it carries on forever but you are only asked to do up to a certain term. I always put a +... at the end, it doesn't matter if you don't but it shows that you understand that the expansion carries on.
Reply 4
Original post by Zacken
It definitely carries on. Using the ++ \cdots \, \, is good practice. In A-Level exams, you'll be asked to "expand up to the term in x^2 or x^3 or whatever" and you can give your final answer without the ellipses.


how did you realise that it would carry on?the text book answer is opposite of yours .The question actually asked me to find the binomial expansion of the mentioned fraction on the attachment up to and including the term in x^2
Reply 5
Original post by PLM98
Like Zacken says, it carries on forever but you are only asked to do up to a certain term. I always put a +... at the end, it doesn't matter if you don't but it shows that you understand that the expansion carries on.


i know for the negative power it carries on and for positive power it wouldn't carry on but here we have both of multiplied by together so that's why it confuses me
Reply 6
Original post by Alen.m
how did you realise that it would carry on?the text book answer is opposite of yours .The question actually asked me to find the binomial expansion of the mentioned fraction on the attachment up to and including the term in x^2


The power series is a sum from n=0/1 to infinity. How is the textbook answer opposite to mine? That's precisely what I said. :tongue:
Reply 7
Original post by Alen.m
i know for the negative power it carries on and for positive power it wouldn't carry on but here we have both of multiplied by together so that's why it confuses me


Well if you have something that doesn't carry on multiplied that does carry on, it's logical to think that the answer would be something that does carry on...
Reply 8
Original post by Zacken
Well if you have something that doesn't carry on multiplied that does carry on, it's logical to think that the answer would be something that does carry on...


yeah i agree with you but here's the text book answer if you wanna take a look at it
Reply 9
Original post by Alen.m
yeah i agree with you but here's the text book answer if you wanna take a look at it


The textbook isn't using == signs. They're throwing away all the terms after the ++ \cdots and saying that the expansion is \approx what they've written.
Reply 10
Original post by Zacken
The textbook isn't using == signs. They're throwing away all the terms after the ++ \cdots and saying that the expansion is \approx what they've written.


yeah that's what i thought as well but again at the end they use the = sign which i think is incorrect because the expansion carries on
Reply 11
Original post by Alen.m
yeah that's what i thought as well but again at the end they use the = sign which i think is incorrect because the expansion carries on


No. They're saying the approximation is equal to that. I could write:

10.5+0.4=0.91 \approx 0.5 + 0.4 = 0.9, that means I'm saying that 10.91 \approx 0.9 even if the last sign is an equals sign. It does not mean I'm saying 1=0.91 = 0.9.
Reply 12
Original post by Zacken
No. They're saying the approximation is equal to that. I could write:

10.5+0.4=0.91 \approx 0.5 + 0.4 = 0.9, that means I'm saying that 10.91 \approx 0.9 even if the last sign is an equals sign. It does not mean I'm saying 1=0.91 = 0.9.


perfectly clear thanks mate
Reply 13
Original post by Alen.m
i know for the negative power it carries on and for positive power it wouldn't carry on but here we have both of multiplied by together so that's why it confuses me


If you are multiplying a finite series by an infinite one, yo get an infinite series. Think about it, you are multiplying an infinite number of terms by the finite series all the time, so it never ends.
Reply 14
too late again ...
Reply 15
Original post by TeeEm
too late again ...

You were missed.
Reply 16
Original post by PLM98
If you are multiplying a finite series by an infinite one, yo get an infinite series. Think about it, you are multiplying an infinite number of terms by the finite series all the time, so it never ends.


it does make sense now thank you

Quick Reply

Latest