So in this question I,m given the discrete random variable (25,0.1)

I,m also told the probability that P(X<a)<0.99

and p(X<=a)>0.99

I could easily do this when I guessed values in my calculator and I got a=6 but I,m very confused about the how you can find it in another way as I don’t think you can do that in a exam.

This is for binomial distrubution

I,m also told the probability that P(X<a)<0.99

and p(X<=a)>0.99

I could easily do this when I guessed values in my calculator and I got a=6 but I,m very confused about the how you can find it in another way as I don’t think you can do that in a exam.

This is for binomial distrubution

(edited 8 months ago)

Scroll to see replies

Original post by realed

So in this question I,m given the random variable (25,0.1)

I,m also told the probability that P(X<a)<0.99

and p(X<=a)>0.99

I could easily do this when I guessed values in my calculator and I got a=6 but I,m very confused about the how you can find it in another way as I don’t think you can do that in a exam.

I,m also told the probability that P(X<a)<0.99

and p(X<=a)>0.99

I could easily do this when I guessed values in my calculator and I got a=6 but I,m very confused about the how you can find it in another way as I don’t think you can do that in a exam.

I believe that some calculators (perhaps the Casio CG-50?) have an inverse binomial distribution function. Otherwise you will need to use the kind of trial and error approach that you've mentioned. In an exam you would normally list the probabilities for a few values of a (say 4, 5, 6 and 7), and form a conclusion (with justification) based on the probabilities found.

(edited 8 months ago)

hey is this for a level edexcel maths?

Original post by realed

So in this question I,m given the random variable (25,0.1)

I,m also told the probability that P(X<a)<0.99

and p(X<=a)>0.99

I could easily do this when I guessed values in my calculator and I got a=6 but I,m very confused about the how you can find it in another way as I don’t think you can do that in a exam.

I,m also told the probability that P(X<a)<0.99

and p(X<=a)>0.99

I could easily do this when I guessed values in my calculator and I got a=6 but I,m very confused about the how you can find it in another way as I don’t think you can do that in a exam.

Have I missed something - you haven't said what distribution it is, only the parameters (25, 0.1) ?

Original post by davros

Have I missed something - you haven't said what distribution it is, only the parameters (25, 0.1) ?

I think it's binomial as it's discrete random variable

Original post by Bookworm524

I think it's binomial as it's discrete random variable

Yeah they put "discrete" in the title, then old_engineer mentioned inverse Normal, but obvs it's going to make a difference what the actual distribution is in terms of how you try to approach the answer

Original post by old_engineer

I believe that some calculators (perhaps the Casio CG-50?) have an inverse normal distribution function. Otherwise you will need to use the kind of trial and error approach that you've mentioned. In an exam you would normally list the probabilities for a few values of a (say 4, 5, 6 and 7), and form a conclusion (with justification) based on the probabilities found.

Thanks, also how do you use the inverse normal thing that you,ve mentioned

(edited 8 months ago)

Original post by study1234okay

hey is this for a level edexcel maths?

This is for OCR Mei further maths(stats) but i think it,s the same thing as the binomial distribution in edexcel stats

(edited 8 months ago)

Original post by davros

Have I missed something - you haven't said what distribution it is, only the parameters (25, 0.1) ?

I forget to say it,s binomial in the description

Original post by realed

I forget to say it,s binomial in the description

So in the past you might have had cumulative binomial tables to help you; these days I suspect a calculator that can do cumulative distributions would be accepted in the exam. Is this an actual "current spec" question, or is it from an old paper / textbook when the spec might have been different?

A back of the envelope approximation would be to use the normal approximation (its on the boundary of what would be ok) so mean (np) 2.5 and std dev (sqrt(np(1-p)) 1.5 so mean + 2 or 3 std devs ~ 6 roughly corresponds to 0.99 cumulative probability. Relatively easy to check the value on your calc then.

Original post by davros

So in the past you might have had cumulative binomial tables to help you; these days I suspect a calculator that can do cumulative distributions would be accepted in the exam. Is this an actual "current spec" question, or is it from an old paper / textbook when the spec might have been different?

This is from the new spec

Original post by mqb2766

A back of the envelope approximation would be to use the normal approximation (its on the boundary of what would be ok) so mean (np) 2.5 and std dev (sqrt(np(1-p)) 1.5 so mean + 2 or 3 std devs ~ 6 roughly corresponds to 0.99 cumulative probability. Relatively easy to check the value on your calc then.

Mean+2=4.5 so how does that correspond to 6

Original post by realed

Mean+2=4.5 so how does that correspond to 6

Its rough, but

2.5 + 3 = 5.5 (2 std devs)

2.5 + 4.5 = 7 (3 std devs)

The probability of 0.99 lies between 0.975 (2 std devs) and 0.9985 (3 std devs). Thinking about it, the numbers of the binomial have almost been chosen to make this simple (variance = 25*0.1*0.9 = 2.25 = 1.5^2).

(edited 8 months ago)

Original post by mqb2766

IIts rough, but

2.5 + 3 = 5.5 (2 std devs)

2.5 + 4.5 = 7 (3 std devs)

The probability of 0.99 lies between 0.975 (2 std devs) and 0.9985 (3 std devs). Thinking about it, the numbers of the binomial have almost been chosen to make this simple (variance = 25*0.1*0.9 = 2.25 = 1.5^2).

2.5 + 3 = 5.5 (2 std devs)

2.5 + 4.5 = 7 (3 std devs)

The probability of 0.99 lies between 0.975 (2 std devs) and 0.9985 (3 std devs). Thinking about it, the numbers of the binomial have almost been chosen to make this simple (variance = 25*0.1*0.9 = 2.25 = 1.5^2).

Ok but why do you decide to just do 2 or 3 standard deviations. You could do 100 or 20000

when you know the answer it makes makes sense but, how do you know this from the question to just use 2 or 3 standard deviations.

(edited 8 months ago)

Original post by realed

Ok but why do you decide to just do 2 or 3 standard deviations. You could do 100 or 20000

when you know the

when you know the

Those values correspond to the stated probability values so

P(X<mean + 2 std dev) = 0.975

P(X<mean + 3 std dev) = 0.9985

which bracket the value 0.99 youre after. You should know that for a normal distribution,

* 68% lies in the interval: mean +/- 1 std dev (so each tail has ~16%)

* 95% lies in the interval: mean +/- 2 std dev (each tail is ~2.5%)

* 99.7% lies in the interval: mean +/- 3 std dev (each tail is 0.15%)

Original post by mqb2766

Those values correspond to the stated probability values so

P(X<mean + 2 std dev) = 0.975

P(X<mean + 3 std dev) = 0.9985

which bracket the value 0.99 youre after. You should know that for a normal distribution,

* 68% lies in the interval: mean +/- 1 std dev (so each tail has ~16%)

* 95% lies in the interval: mean +/- 2 std dev (each tail is ~2.5%)

* 99.7% lies in the interval: mean +/- 3 std dev (each tail is 0.15%)

P(X<mean + 2 std dev) = 0.975

P(X<mean + 3 std dev) = 0.9985

which bracket the value 0.99 youre after. You should know that for a normal distribution,

* 68% lies in the interval: mean +/- 1 std dev (so each tail has ~16%)

* 95% lies in the interval: mean +/- 2 std dev (each tail is ~2.5%)

* 99.7% lies in the interval: mean +/- 3 std dev (each tail is 0.15%)

Firstly when I put but x is less than 5.5 in my calculator i get an argument error, also when I put x is less than or equal to 7 I get 0.9977 but I assume that with this you look for the highest standard deviation below the answer and the lowest standard deviation above the answer and you find the smallest that a can be that satisfies this equation.

(edited 8 months ago)

Original post by realed

Firstly when I put but x is less than 5.5 in my calculator i get an argument error, also when I put x is less than or equal to 7 I get 0.9977 but I assume that with this you look for the highest standard deviation below the answer and the lowest standard deviation above the answer and you find the smallest that a can be that satisfies this equation.

Ill drop out. You cant put a fraction in your binomial for x (so 5 or 6, not 5.5) and as in the first post, the normal approximation of the binomial is rough here because its on the boundary of when it can be used, so the probabilities will not be exact. For me, it said your answer for the binomial was around 6 (maybe 5 or 7) and would be easy to verify on your calculator using the actual binomial distribution.

Original post by mqb2766

I’ll drop out. You cant put a fraction in your binomial for x (so 5 or 6, not 5.5) and as in the first post, the normal approximation of the binomial is rough here because its on the boundary of when it can be used, so the probabilities will not be exact. For me, it said your answer for the binomial was around 6 (maybe 5 or 7) and would be easy to verify on your calculator using the actual binomial distribution.

Ok but if you have a fraction like 5.5 can you find the values for 5 and 6 and then work out the mean .Also., thanks for helping me I really appreciate it.

(edited 8 months ago)

- 6 markers
- Maths Thought/Question
- Probability help
- Hypothesis testing - confused about critical region for two tailed tests
- Further Maths Choice
- warwick: maths or discrete maths
- People who do Computer Science in Uni: How much mathematics do you do?
- Strong degree for becoming a strong quant?
- Becoming a maths teacher, but have barely studied one of the Further Maths topics
- Changing Courses at Warwick from Economics to Discrete Maths
- Question for people taking Discrete Maths at Warwick
- Negative Binomial Question
- What are my options?
- Judicial Review question law
- Will I be accepted with A*AE?
- Ucl ucas mistake
- Let me help you grow your grades
- Economics, Finance and Data Science
- Computer Science Degree
- A level probability maths

- MPhil in Bioscience Enterprise at Cambridge.
- Queen Mary Malta A100 2024 Entry
- AI
- Tatakae L's GYG Journey
- Official: Kent and Medway Medical School A100 2024 entry
- Last Person To Post Here Wins (Part 54)
- Diagnostic Radiography Applicants 2024
- Economics modules
- Official Oxford 2024 Postgraduate Applicants Thread
- should I ask my crush out
- [Official thread] Hamas-Israel Conflict
- I think I'm (possibly) dead
- Will my father on a government pension, private pension
- The daily Wordle puzzle thread!
- Official London School of Economics and Political Science 2024 Applicant Thread
- TSR Community Awards 2023 - VOTING NOW OPEN!
- Grade Growth Chronicles | From C's to A's (23-24)
- MSc Social Science of the Internet 2024-25
- Would you rather attend...?
- Calling sturniolo triplet fans!!!

- The daily Connections puzzle thread
- Help urgent advise/ input
- Help life talk
- UCL EISPS application for 2024 entry
- lnat results thread 2024
- Breakfast items hurt/heal game!
- The G20 Leaders Hurt/Heal Game
- World cuisines hurt/heal game
- GCSE revision help
- English County Hurt / Heal Game
- The Fast Food Restaurants Hurt/Heal game
- UCL Medicine A100 2024
- The Cambridge College Hurt/Heal Game [part 2]
- Ofcom graduate scheme 2024
- bupa graduate scheme 2024
- What are you listening to now thread XI
- NHS Graduate Management Training Scheme 2024 start
- [M21]Going to the gym didn’t make me more confident
- gyg: My Villain Origin Story 💣👽🙌🧠
- Who's your celebrity crush?

- Mock set 4 paper 2 q14 a level maths (4 distinct points)
- UKMT Intermediate Math Challenge 2024 - Discussion
- Help with complex summation further maths a levels
- GCSE Mathematics Study Group 2023-2024
- Could I have some help with this suvat question?
- MAT practice
- A-level Mathematics Study Group 2023-2024
- Alevel Maths Question
- weird cosine question
- Series function not differentiable at a point

- hyperbolic function catenary problem
- can anyone answer this A level vectors question (very challenging)
- STEP foundation module help pls
- Ukmt IMC 2024
- ukmt imc
- This maths question is driving me crazy
- Maths Mechanics
- Confused on surds question
- HNC MATHS A2 Task 3 (Radio Transmitters)
- Senior Maths Challenge 2023

- Mock set 4 paper 2 q14 a level maths (4 distinct points)
- UKMT Intermediate Math Challenge 2024 - Discussion
- Help with complex summation further maths a levels
- GCSE Mathematics Study Group 2023-2024
- Could I have some help with this suvat question?
- MAT practice
- A-level Mathematics Study Group 2023-2024
- Alevel Maths Question
- weird cosine question
- Series function not differentiable at a point

- hyperbolic function catenary problem
- can anyone answer this A level vectors question (very challenging)
- STEP foundation module help pls
- Ukmt IMC 2024
- ukmt imc
- This maths question is driving me crazy
- Maths Mechanics
- Confused on surds question
- HNC MATHS A2 Task 3 (Radio Transmitters)
- Senior Maths Challenge 2023