If you mean English Literature, then either one is good! Go for the one you enjoy! They're both facilitating subjects. However, you don't really have a strong essay subject, so English Lit would be good to fulfil that requirement for uni applications...
If you mean English Language, then do maths (unless you really want to do English Lang). Maths is MUCH more respected by universities than English Language, unless you are hoping to study something related to English Language at uni.