The Student Room Group

Poll: the best rap producer of all time is?

Scroll to see replies

Original post by Andy98
Yeah, Kanye seems to be kinda like Marmite - some people love him, some people hate him (if you hadn't guessed I'm the latter :tongue:)

Can't say I've heard that one - I'll give it a listen later


I'm in the middle. Made some great stuff. It really annoys me when people say he's crap because he's a bellend or especially because it's Hip-Hop music. It also annoys me when the Stans say he's the greatest ever or MBDTF is the best thing since whatever.

Nice one. Remember seeing the video for TTW and loved it, bought the album and hammered it summer '04 :cool:
Original post by Wilfred Little
I'm in the middle. Made some great stuff. It really annoys me when people say he's crap because he's a bellend or especially because it's Hip-Hop music. It also annoys me when the Stans say he's the greatest ever or MBDTF is the best thing since whatever.

Nice one. Remember seeing the video for TTW and loved it, bought the album and hammered it summer '04 :cool:


Oh yeah, he is a colossal ****; but that doesn't make his music **** :tongue:

Haha cool, I ain't that old though :tongue:
Original post by Andy98
I've heard a few tracks from each of those, they were very meh


Nah what tracks were meh because u trippin if you think any of MBDTF was meh
Original post by blessings2theHOU
Nah what tracks were meh because u trippin if you think any of MBDTF was meh


Monster, All of the Lights, Power, Hell Of A Life
None of them.
Barely any of them have written their own songs anyway.

2 words:
Beastie Boys

[video="youtube;eBShN8qT4lk"]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eBShN8qT4lk&list=PLJdDgfq34Jz3eFlFgemfFHS8MM WbSRtyA[/video]
Original post by Andy98
Monster, All of the Lights, Power, Hell Of A Life


Power is arguably the best produced rap song of the decade
Hell of a life is incredible and that electric guitar is the work of God
Ok monster was okay at best but Nicki's verse holy ****>>>>
All of the lights was a really good pop song regardless of how you look at it
Original post by DMcGovern
None of them.
Barely any of them have written their own songs anyway.

2 words:
Beastie Boys

[video="youtube;eBShN8qT4lk"]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eBShN8qT4lk&list=PLJdDgfq34Jz3eFlFgemfFHS8MM WbSRtyA[/video]


That's because they're producers, not writers:smile:
What about Eminem?
Original post by blessings2theHOU
That's because they're producers, not writers:smile:


Then this

Original post by thefatone
What about Eminem?
Original post by thefatone
What about Eminem?


Once again, eminems production discography is no where near as special as the discogs' of people on this list
Original post by DMcGovern
Then this


Lol the beastie boys are overrated tbh
Eminems parents obv
Original post by blessings2theHOU
Power is arguably the best produced rap song of the decade


Oh, OK. Well I think Elzhi's One Love is the best produced track of the decade.
Original post by blessings2theHOU
Power is arguably the best produced rap song of the decade
Hell of a life is incredible and that electric guitar is the work of God
Ok monster was okay at best but Nicki's verse holy ****>>>>
All of the lights was a really good pop song regardless of how you look at it


The guitar I'll give you
Power was crap, it was hardly rap
Nicki Minaj is just unbearable, Jays verse was ok though
All of the lights was more a case of me not being into modern pop tbh, but I will admit that one was good for the genre.
Original post by Wilfred Little
Oh, OK. Well I think Elzhi's One Love is the best produced track of the decade.


Note that I said "arguably"

On the real though you're objectively wrong if you don't think that My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy is the best produced album so far of the decade
Original post by Andy98
The guitar I'll give you
Power was crap, it was hardly rap
Nicki Minaj is just unbearable, Jays verse was ok though
All of the lights was more a case of me not being into modern pop tbh, but I will admit that one was good for the genre.


Power was rap, that's probably the most lyrical Kanye has been since his LR days.
+those intricate samples are crazy

Tf you talking about nicki being unbearable? She murdered Jay and Ye on monster and that's a universally accepted fact
Original post by blessings2theHOU
Note that I said "arguably"

On the real though you're objectively wrong if you don't think that My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy is the best produced album so far of the decade


Am I? I think David Bowie's Blackstar is better.
Original post by Wilfred Little
Am I? I think David Bowie's Blackstar is better.


You're wrong tbh
Not that blackstar was a bad album at all though

I hope you know what I mean when I say "best produced"
(edited 8 years ago)
Original post by blessings2theHOU
Power was rap, that's probably the most lyrical Kanye has been since his LR days.
+those intricate samples are crazy

Tf you talking about nicki being unbearable? She murdered Jay and Ye on monster and that's a universally accepted fact


Honestly wasn't that good. I could probably write better lyrics for the track

Nicki is unbearable - especially when she starts barking like a seal.
Original post by blessings2theHOU
You're wrong tbh
Not that black star was a bad album at all though


Blackstar is much, much better. Kanye West would probably admit it himself. He certainly acknowledged Bowie as an influence on him when he died.

The title track alone pisses over everything Kanye has ever done. Honestly think it's a top five Bowie record and I'm including all of the 70s output in that.

Quick Reply

Latest