# The Proof is Trivial!

Watch
Announcements

I noticed that the mathematics forum is currently lacking a thread where people can post interesting and challenging problems for fellow mathematicians to ponder, so here it is.

**Please don't post here for queries on A level or STEP questions**, as they each have their respective threads. The level of the questions can of course vary, but they should be fun, interesting, and most importantly solvable! Please don't post questions that you're not able or willing to provide solutions to. Questions that require knowledge of graduate level theorems won't be of interest to most of us, so keep the level reasonable.

Use the following format for problems and solutions:

(example)

*****= requires only A-level knowledge

******= may require a little extra (induction, L'hôpital's etc.)

*******= requires undergraduate knowledge

(the stars do not reflect the difficulty of the question)

Please LaTex all problems and solutions, and remember to spoiler any hints.

Below is a set of links to the problems/solutions posted in the thread. Please remember to number your problem accordingly.

Problem 1 · Solution (electriic_ink)

Problem 2 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 3 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 4 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 5 · Solution (Felix Felicis)

Problem 6 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 7 · Solution (j.alexanderh)

Problem 8 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 9 · Solution (Noble.)

Problem 10 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 11 · Solution (Smaug123)

Problem 12 · Solution (und) · Solution 2 (LLewellyn)

Problem 13 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 14 · Solution (Noble.) · Solution 2 (metaltron) · Solution 3 (Hasufel)

Problem 15 · Solution (_Izzy)

Problem 16 · Solution (Farhan.Hanif93)

Problem 17 · Solution (und)

Problem 18 · Solution (Smaug123)

Problem 19 · Solution (und)

Problem 20 · Solution (Felix Felicis)

Problem 21 · Solution (und)

Problem 22 · Solution (und)

Problem 23 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 24 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 25 · Solution (Mladenov) Comments

Problem 26 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 27 · Solution to first part (Star-girl)

Problem 28 · Solution (Felix Felicis)

Problem 29 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 30 · Solution (und)

Problem 31 · Solution (Upper Echelons)

Problem 32 · Solution (Felix Felicis)

Problem 33 · Solutions 1 & 2 (Lord of the Flies) · Solution 3 (Star-girl) Solution 4 (Felix Felicis)

Problem 34 · Solution (DJMayes) · Solution 2 (metaltron)

Problem 35 · Solution (Felix Felicis)

Problem 36 · Solution (Felix Felicis)

Problem 37 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 38 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 39

Problem 40 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 41 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 42 · Solution (Noble.)

Problem 43 · Solution (und)

Problem 44 · Solution (jack.hadamard) · Comments

Problem 45 · Solution (und)

Problem 46 · Solution (DJMayes)

Problem 47 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 48 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 49 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 50 · Solution (Star-girl) · Solution 2 (DJMayes) · Solution 3 (und)

Problem 51

Problem 52 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 53 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 54 · Solution (metaltron) · Comments · Comments

Problem 55 · Solution (Llewellyn)

Problem 56 · Solution (Felix Felicis)

Problem 57 · Solution (Farhan.Hanif93)

Problem 58 · Solution (bananarama2)

Problem 59 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 60 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 61 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 62 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 63 · Solution (bananarama2)

Problem 64 · Solution (Mladenov) · Comments

Problem 65

Problem 66 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 67 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 68 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 69 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (ben-smith)

Problem 70 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 71 · Solution (james22)

Problem 72 · Solution (Indeterminate)

Problem 73 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 74

Problem 75 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 76 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (Jkn) · Solution 3 (Jkn) · Solution 4 (Jkn)

Problem 77 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 78 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 79 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 80 · Solution (Lord of the Flies) · Solution 2 (Jkn) · Solution 3 (Zephyr1011)

Problem 81

Problem 82

Problem 83

Problem 84

Problem 85 · Solution (Jkn)

Problem 86 · Solution (Jkn) · Solution 2 (james22)

Problem 87 · Solution (MW24595)

Problem 88 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (Zephyr1011) · Solution 3 (Jkn)

Problem 89 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 90 · Solution (metaltron) · Solution to second part (Jkn)

Problem 91 · Solution (Jkn)

Problem 92 · Solution (Lord of the Flies) · Solution 2 (Jkn)

Problem 93 · Solution (Mladenov) · Comments

Problem 94 · Solution (Zephyr1011) · Solution 2 (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 95 · Solution (Jkn)

Problem 96

Problem 97 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 98 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 99 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 100 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 101 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 102 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 103 · Solution (ben-smith) · Solution 2 (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 104 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 105 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 106 · Solution (Lord of the Flies) · Solution 2 (Jkn)

Problem 107 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 108 · Solution (und) · Solution 2 (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 109 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 110 · Solution (FireGarden)

Problem 111 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 112 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 113

Problem 114 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 115 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 116

Problem 117 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 118

Problem 119 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 120 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 121 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 122

Problem 123 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 124 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 125

Problem 126 · Solution (ben-smith)

Problem 127 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 128 · Solution (bananarama2)

Problem 129 · Solution (bananarama2)

Problem 130 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 131 · Solution (ben-smith)

Problem 132 · Solution (Felix Felicis) · Solution 2 (ben-smith)

Problem 133 · Solution (Felix Felicis) · Solution 2 (Mladenov)

Problem 134 · Solution (ben-smith)

Problem 135 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 136

Problem 137 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 138

Problem 139 · Solution (Mladenov) · Extension · Solution to extension (Mladenov)

Problem 140 · Solution (Felix Felicis) · Solution 2 (Lord of the Flies) · Solution 3 (Mladenov)

Problem 141

Problem 142 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 143

Problem 144

Problem 145 · Solution (jack.hadamard)

Problem 146 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 147 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 148 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 149

Problem 150 · Solution (bananarama2)

Problem 151

Problem 152

Problem 153

Problem 154 · Solution (Jkn)

Problem 155

(cont. in post 2)

(N.B. If a solution has been posted but you wish to add your own contribution, please feel free; both will be linked to in this post.)

37

reply

Problem 156 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (ben-smith) · Solution 3 (Jkn)

Problem 157 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 158 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 159 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 160 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 161

Problem 162 · Hint

Problem 163 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 164 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 165

Problem 166 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 167

Problem 168 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (Felix Felicis)

Problem 169 · Solution (Lord of the Flies) · Solution 2 (Jkn)

Problem 170 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 171 · Solution 1 (DJMayes) · Solution 2 (Zakee)

Problem 172 · Solution to first part (DJMayes) · Solution to second part (Zakee)

Problem 173 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 174 · Solution (Felix Felicis) · Solution 2 (Jkn)

Problem 175 · Solution (Felix Felicis) Solution 2 (DJMayes)

Problem 176 · Solution (joostan)

Problem 177 · Solution (Felix Felicis)

Problem 178 · Solution (DJMayes) · Solution 2 (Jkn)

Problem 179 · Solution (joostan)

Problem 180 · Solution (Felix Felicis)

Problem 181

Problem 182

Problem 183 · Solution (joostan) · Solution 2 (Jkn)

Problem 184 · Solution (DJMayes) · Solution 2 (LewisMead)

Problem 185 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 186 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 187 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 188 · Solution (Jkn)

Problem 189 · Solution (Benjy100)

Problem 190 · Solution (Felix Felicis) · Solution 2 (such) · Solution 3 (LewisMead)

Problem 191 · Solution (Felix Felicis)

Problem 192 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 193 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 194

Problem 195 · Solution (DJMayes) · Solution 2 (Mladenov)

Problem 196 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 197 · Solution (metaltron)

Problem 198

Problem 199

Problem 200 · Solution (Felix Felicis) · Problem 200 · Solution (jack.hadamard)

Problem 201 · Solution (bananarama2)

Problem 202 · Solution (DJMayes) · Problem 202

Problem 203

Problem 204

Problem 205

Problem 206 · Solution (bananarama2)

Problem 207

Problem 208

Problem 209 · Solution (MW24595)

Problem 210 · Solution (MW24595) Solution 2 (Jkn)

Problem 211 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 212 · Solution (Jkn) · Solution 2 (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 213 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 214 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 215 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 216 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 217 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 218 · Solution (joostan)

Problem 219 · Solution (ukdragon37)

Problem 220

Problem 221 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 222 · Solution (Jkn)

Problem 223 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 224 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 225

Problem 227

Problem 228

Problem 229 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 230 · Solution (Lord of the Flies) · Solution 2 (ukdragon37)

Problem 231 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (Jkn)

Problem 232 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 233 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (Jkn) · Solution 3 (Jkn)

Problem 234

Problem 235 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 236 · Solution (The Polymath) · Solution 2 (henpen)

Problem 237 · Solution (Felix Felicis)

Problem 238 · Solution (The Polymath)

Problem 239 · Solution (james22)

Problem 240 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 241 · Solution (TheMagicMan) · Solution 2 (Jkn)

Problem 242

Problem 243 · Solution (Ateo)

Problem 244

Problem 245 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 246 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 247 · Solution (FireGarden)

Problem 248

Problem 249

Problem 250 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (Blutooth)

Problem 251 · Solution (jack.hadamard)

Problem 252

Problem 253

Problem 254

Problem 255

Problem 256

(N.B. If a solution has been posted but you wish to add your own contribution, please feel free; both will be linked to in this post.)

Problem 157 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 158 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 159 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 160 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 161

Problem 162 · Hint

Problem 163 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 164 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 165

Problem 166 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 167

Problem 168 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (Felix Felicis)

Problem 169 · Solution (Lord of the Flies) · Solution 2 (Jkn)

Problem 170 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 171 · Solution 1 (DJMayes) · Solution 2 (Zakee)

Problem 172 · Solution to first part (DJMayes) · Solution to second part (Zakee)

Problem 173 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 174 · Solution (Felix Felicis) · Solution 2 (Jkn)

Problem 175 · Solution (Felix Felicis) Solution 2 (DJMayes)

Problem 176 · Solution (joostan)

Problem 177 · Solution (Felix Felicis)

Problem 178 · Solution (DJMayes) · Solution 2 (Jkn)

Problem 179 · Solution (joostan)

Problem 180 · Solution (Felix Felicis)

Problem 181

Problem 182

Problem 183 · Solution (joostan) · Solution 2 (Jkn)

Problem 184 · Solution (DJMayes) · Solution 2 (LewisMead)

Problem 185 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 186 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 187 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 188 · Solution (Jkn)

Problem 189 · Solution (Benjy100)

Problem 190 · Solution (Felix Felicis) · Solution 2 (such) · Solution 3 (LewisMead)

Problem 191 · Solution (Felix Felicis)

Problem 192 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 193 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 194

Problem 195 · Solution (DJMayes) · Solution 2 (Mladenov)

Problem 196 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 197 · Solution (metaltron)

Problem 198

Problem 199

Problem 200 · Solution (Felix Felicis) · Problem 200 · Solution (jack.hadamard)

Problem 201 · Solution (bananarama2)

Problem 202 · Solution (DJMayes) · Problem 202

Problem 203

Problem 204

Problem 205

Problem 206 · Solution (bananarama2)

Problem 207

Problem 208

Problem 209 · Solution (MW24595)

Problem 210 · Solution (MW24595) Solution 2 (Jkn)

Problem 211 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 212 · Solution (Jkn) · Solution 2 (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 213 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 214 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 215 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 216 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 217 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 218 · Solution (joostan)

Problem 219 · Solution (ukdragon37)

Problem 220

Problem 221 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 222 · Solution (Jkn)

Problem 223 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 224 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 225

Problem 227

Problem 228

Problem 229 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 230 · Solution (Lord of the Flies) · Solution 2 (ukdragon37)

Problem 231 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (Jkn)

Problem 232 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 233 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (Jkn) · Solution 3 (Jkn)

Problem 234

Problem 235 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 236 · Solution (The Polymath) · Solution 2 (henpen)

Problem 237 · Solution (Felix Felicis)

Problem 238 · Solution (The Polymath)

Problem 239 · Solution (james22)

Problem 240 · Solution (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 241 · Solution (TheMagicMan) · Solution 2 (Jkn)

Problem 242

Problem 243 · Solution (Ateo)

Problem 244

Problem 245 · Solution (Mladenov)

Problem 246 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (Lord of the Flies)

Problem 247 · Solution (FireGarden)

Problem 248

Problem 249

Problem 250 · Solution (Mladenov) · Solution 2 (Blutooth)

Problem 251 · Solution (jack.hadamard)

Problem 252

Problem 253

Problem 254

Problem 255

Problem 256

(N.B. If a solution has been posted but you wish to add your own contribution, please feel free; both will be linked to in this post.)

**Prove that if the function is continuous on and for any continuous function , then on .**

Problem 1*

Problem 1*

1

reply

Report

#3

(Original post by

**und**)**Problem 1***

Prove that if the function is continuous on and for any continuous function , then on .
Spoiler:

Show

Suppose f is non-zero and satisfies the relation. Then f^2 is non-negative and is strictly positive on some open subinterval of [a, b] (by continuity). So the integral of f^2 is positive, which contradicts "integral of fg = 0" (take g=f).

2

reply

Report

#4

I'll the post the next problem. Undergraduates will probably find it pretty easy and it can be done with GCSE knowledge.

Define a function f:R → R using the following rule:

"For any x,y∈R, f(x+y)=f(x)f(y)"

Show that, if f is non-zero:

(a) f(0)=1

(b) f(x)=0 has no solutions

(c) f(-x)=1/f(x)

**Problem 2***Define a function f:R → R using the following rule:

"For any x,y∈R, f(x+y)=f(x)f(y)"

Show that, if f is non-zero:

(a) f(0)=1

(b) f(x)=0 has no solutions

(c) f(-x)=1/f(x)

1

reply

Report

#7

I'm getting too old for this

Spoiler:

Show

This is the subscribing post, of course

0

reply

Report

#9

**Problem 4***

If N is any perfect power of 2 (i.e. N=2^n for some integer n) then there is no number, M, formed by permutating the digits of N, which is also a perfect power of 2.

0

reply

Report

#10

**und**)

**Problem 1***

Prove that if the function is continuous on and for any continuous function , then on .

even though all the criteria specified hold here.

EDIT: In fact, we don't even need to look to orthogonal functions. Take to be either odd or even, then choose to be of opposite parity. Then the product is odd. Take the interval and the integral of shall be zero as it is odd, and integrated over symmetric limits.

0

reply

(Original post by

That's not true, otherwise there would not exist non-trivial orthogonal functions. For a concrete example;

even though all the criteria specified hold here.

**FireGarden**)That's not true, otherwise there would not exist non-trivial orthogonal functions. For a concrete example;

even though all the criteria specified hold here.

*any*continuous function g, not just one example of your choice.

0

reply

Report

#12

**Problem 5****

__De Moivre's Theorem__By considering the real and imaginary parts of:

Prove that

and that

Show also that:

Where

Derive another expression for:

Where

2

reply

1

reply

Report

#15

(Original post by

This doesn't seem particularly fun, interesting or challenging. It looks like it's straight out of a standard A level textbook exercise!

**und**)This doesn't seem particularly fun, interesting or challenging. It looks like it's straight out of a standard A level textbook exercise!

0

reply

Report

#16

(Original post by

Are you sure?

**Mr M**)Are you sure?

Thanks for spotting my error.

0

reply

(Original post by

I'm typing up the second part of the problem. I accidentally submitted before I finished.

**joostan**)I'm typing up the second part of the problem. I accidentally submitted before I finished.

0

reply

Report

#18

(Original post by

Is that a STEP question?

**und**)Is that a STEP question?

0

reply

Report

#19

**Solution 4**

Suppose their exist distinct integers n, m such that 2^n and 2^m satisfy the desired property. Then:

(a number is always congruent to its digit sum mod 9)

However, this implies n = 6k+m which in turn implies that 2^n and 2^m cannot have the same number of digits. Hence no such n, m exist.

1

reply

Report

#20

As expected, the problems I'm interested in are more quaint than the usual Here's one that's strange but rather easy once you get it.

Let where we define for all , . For any set we write to denote the smallest member of such that for all . (Hence .)

Let be a function such that:

Show that the value

EDIT: Right I see where people are getting confused. is

**Problem 6**/*****Let where we define for all , . For any set we write to denote the smallest member of such that for all . (Hence .)

Let be a function such that:

Show that the value

*F*given by satisfies and is the smallest member of to do so.EDIT: Right I see where people are getting confused. is

*not*a variable - it is actually an element in addition to the naturals that is defined to be greater than or equal to all of them. See it as an element representing "infinity".
0

reply

X

### Quick Reply

Back

to top

to top