Turn on thread page Beta

European Commission signal stance of effectively keeping NI in EU Customs Union rules watch

    • Section Leader
    • Clearing and Applications Advisor
    • Thread Starter

    Section Leader
    Clearing and Applications Advisor
    As per the FT:

    (Original post by FT)
    Keep Northern Ireland in customs union, says EU

    The EU is demanding Britain accept that Northern Ireland may need to remain inside the European customs union and single market after Brexit to avoid “a hard border on the island of Ireland”.

    The explicit mention of an “all-island” approach by Dublin and Brussels directly contradicts the UK position and will infuriate the Democratic Unionist party, on whose votes Theresa May’s government depends for a parliamentary majority at Westminster.

    The European Commission on Wednesday circulated an update on negotiations, seen by the Financial Times, which concludes that the avoidance of “regulatory divergence” on the island of Ireland is “essential” to protect the peace process.

    “It consequently seems essential for the UK to commit to ensuring that a hard border on the island of Ireland is avoided, including by ensuring no emergence of regulatory divergence from those rules of the internal market and the customs union,” the paper states.

    The commission adds that the regulatory arrangements “are (or may be in the future) necessary for meaningful North-South co-operation, the all-island economy and the protection of the Good Friday Agreement”.

    The statement comes days after James Brokenshire, the Northern Ireland secretary, made clear that it would be “impossible” to imagine Belfast remaining within the EU’s customs union and single market, in effect creating a trade border along the Irish Sea after Brexit.

    “We will leave the EU in 2019 as one United Kingdom,” Mr Brokenshire said in Brussels on Monday. “We need to ensure that nothing is done that undermines the integrity of the UK single market.”

    He added: “I find it difficult to imagine how Northern Ireland could somehow remain in while the rest of the country leaves. I find it impossible.”

    The commission stance on the potential need for an all-island regulatory solution reflects the hardening position in Dublin over border issues as the Brexit divorce negotiations enter a critical phase.

    One senior EU official said the Irish felt they were reaching a point of “maximum leverage” and were “really worried” by the UK position, which insists the Irish border questions can only be fully addressed through a UK-EU trade deal.

    Another negotiator involved in talks noted Ireland’s firm stance was becoming a “wild card” factor in the efforts to make “sufficient progress” in divorce talks by December so that talks on UK-EU future relations can begin.

    Both Britain and the EU say they are committed to ensuring that Brexit does not undermine the 1998 Good Friday peace agreement or lead to the emergence of hard-border infrastructure between the Republic and Northern Ireland.

    Significant progress has been made in the six rounds of Brexit talks to date, including agreement on joint principles to maintain the Common Travel Area between the UK and Ireland. But the border issue has remained far from resolved.

    Sensitivities over Northern Ireland have been exacerbated by the UK government’s reliance on the DUP for its parliamentary majority and by the breakdown in Northern Ireland’s power-sharing arrangements, which have left it without an executive since January. The DUP reject the idea of any special arrangements after Brexit that would keep Northern Ireland within the EU’s regulatory orbit.

    Dublin has long said Britain should stay in the customs union, reducing many but not all of the political and practical challenges over the Northern Ireland border. Irish officials question the feasibility of the “invisible” border proposed by the UK, with imports and exports being notified online.

    Given the practical challenges of the UK leaving the customs union, Simon Coveney, Irish foreign minister, has called for a transition period of up to five years after Brexit, well in excess of the two years suggested by London.

    Leo Varadkar, the Irish prime minister, said this week that he was “more optimistic” that a deal on divorce talks could be reached by the end of the year.

    But he added that the ultimate decision “will, of course, all depend on what happens over the next number of weeks and what specific assurances and written guarantees we can get from the UK”.
    Working Paper link here: https://static.rasset.ie/documents/n...1/eu-paper.pdf

    Even if not explicit in keeping Northern Ireland within the Customs Union and the Single Market itself, regulatory equivalence would essentially mean that the current status of trade could only be maintained by following the rules set out by the EU which may differ from the policies of the UK government after Brexit. As detailed in the article, that would be a stark contrast to the DUP's position that anything separating Northern Ireland from the rest of the country should be rejected.

    Do you think this is simply part of the 'opening round' over Northern Ireland with both sides expecting to move towards a compromise, or do you think the EC are taking this position under the expectation that the UK will agree with it? Seeing as the stability of Theresa May's government relies substantially on DUP support on major legislation, what are the implications of this on the rest of the partnership if the Conservatives do back down and agree to the EC's position?
    • TSR Support Team
    • Peer Support Volunteers
    • Clearing and Applications Advisor

    TSR Support Team
    Peer Support Volunteers
    Clearing and Applications Advisor
    I welcome this working paper and its findings of sorts. Simple fact is, NI needs to remain under EU Custom rules. Our trade links with southern Ireland are incredibly large, and the problems would be massive if we left. Agriculture springs to mind for this, with many farms in NI on the border and trading with our ROI Ulster counterparts.
    • TSR Support Team
    • Clearing and Applications Advisor

    TSR Support Team
    Clearing and Applications Advisor
    I think this is a non-starter, quite apart from the DUP issue, I just don't see how this could work on a practical level. Here's a better idea: the UK joins EFTA, everyone's happy. Well, not Farage, but who cares about him?

    So, Ireland, NI and the EU says there can be no hard border between Ireland and NI.
    UK says there can be no hard border within the UK.
    Therefore, there can be no hard border between the EU and the UK.
Which accompaniment is best?
Useful resources

The Student Room, Get Revising and Marked by Teachers are trading names of The Student Room Group Ltd.

Register Number: 04666380 (England and Wales), VAT No. 806 8067 22 Registered Office: International House, Queens Road, Brighton, BN1 3XE

Write a reply...
Reputation gems: You get these gems as you gain rep from other members for making good contributions and giving helpful advice.