The fly-press shown below is used by a jeweller to punch shapes out of a thin metal sheet.

The frame holds a screw and punch. Two arms are attached to the screw, each loaded with a heavy steel ball. The screw is driven downwards when the arms are rotated.

Kinetic energy is stored in the rotating parts: the balls, arms, screw and punch. This energy is used to punch the shape out of the metal sheet.

Q)For thicker or stiffer metal sheets the rotational kinetic energy at 2.9 rev s–1 is not enough to punch out the shape.

The distance from the axis of rotation to the centre of each ball is y.

The radius of each ball is R.

The stored energy can be increased by

either

• increasing y by 15% without changing R

or

• increasing R by 15% without changing y.

Deduce which of these would produce the greater increase in stored energy.

- I got to the right conclusion that increasing R by 15% without changing y would produce the greater increase in stored energy I just used the logic of I=mr^2 and r=R+y so is R is bigger increasing R would obviously do more.

-However the mark scheme says:

(I = 2 mr2 and Ek = ½ I ω2)

Increasing y by 15% gives new I = 1.15^2 × original I (or 1.32) ✔

Increasing R by 15% increases I by 1.15^3 (or 1.52) ✔

Second option gives greater increase in I, and Ek

also increased (by same ratio). ✔

Accept answers without calculation:

I prop to y^2 ✔

I prop to R^3 ✔

I don't understand how they got

>I prop to y^2 ✔

>I prop to R^3 ✔

The frame holds a screw and punch. Two arms are attached to the screw, each loaded with a heavy steel ball. The screw is driven downwards when the arms are rotated.

Kinetic energy is stored in the rotating parts: the balls, arms, screw and punch. This energy is used to punch the shape out of the metal sheet.

Q)For thicker or stiffer metal sheets the rotational kinetic energy at 2.9 rev s–1 is not enough to punch out the shape.

The distance from the axis of rotation to the centre of each ball is y.

The radius of each ball is R.

The stored energy can be increased by

either

• increasing y by 15% without changing R

or

• increasing R by 15% without changing y.

Deduce which of these would produce the greater increase in stored energy.

- I got to the right conclusion that increasing R by 15% without changing y would produce the greater increase in stored energy I just used the logic of I=mr^2 and r=R+y so is R is bigger increasing R would obviously do more.

-However the mark scheme says:

(I = 2 mr2 and Ek = ½ I ω2)

Increasing y by 15% gives new I = 1.15^2 × original I (or 1.32) ✔

Increasing R by 15% increases I by 1.15^3 (or 1.52) ✔

Second option gives greater increase in I, and Ek

also increased (by same ratio). ✔

Accept answers without calculation:

I prop to y^2 ✔

I prop to R^3 ✔

I don't understand how they got

>I prop to y^2 ✔

>I prop to R^3 ✔

(edited 1 month ago)

Original post by 1234kelly

The fly-press shown below is used by a jeweller to punch shapes out of a thin metal sheet.

...

...

Shown where?

Original post by Eimmanuel

Shown where?

Original post by 1234kelly

The fly-press shown below is used by a jeweller to punch shapes out of a thin metal sheet.

The frame holds a screw and punch. Two arms are attached to the screw, each loaded with a heavy steel ball. The screw is driven downwards when the arms are rotated.

Kinetic energy is stored in the rotating parts: the balls, arms, screw and punch. This energy is used to punch the shape out of the metal sheet.

Q)For thicker or stiffer metal sheets the rotational kinetic energy at 2.9 rev s–1 is not enough to punch out the shape.

The distance from the axis of rotation to the centre of each ball is y.

The radius of each ball is R.

The stored energy can be increased by

either

• increasing y by 15% without changing R

or

• increasing R by 15% without changing y.

Deduce which of these would produce the greater increase in stored energy.

- I got to the right conclusion that increasing R by 15% without changing y would produce the greater increase in stored energy I just used the logic of I=mr^2 and r=R+y so is R is bigger increasing R would obviously do more.

-However the mark scheme says:

(I = 2 mr2 and Ek = ½ I ω2)

Increasing y by 15% gives new I = 1.15^2 × original I (or 1.32) ✔

Increasing R by 15% increases I by 1.15^3 (or 1.52) ✔

Second option gives greater increase in I, and Ek

also increased (by same ratio). ✔

Accept answers without calculation:

I prop to y^2 ✔

I prop to R^3 ✔

I don't understand how they got

>I prop to y^2 ✔

>I prop to R^3 ✔

The frame holds a screw and punch. Two arms are attached to the screw, each loaded with a heavy steel ball. The screw is driven downwards when the arms are rotated.

Kinetic energy is stored in the rotating parts: the balls, arms, screw and punch. This energy is used to punch the shape out of the metal sheet.

Q)For thicker or stiffer metal sheets the rotational kinetic energy at 2.9 rev s–1 is not enough to punch out the shape.

The distance from the axis of rotation to the centre of each ball is y.

The radius of each ball is R.

The stored energy can be increased by

either

• increasing y by 15% without changing R

or

• increasing R by 15% without changing y.

Deduce which of these would produce the greater increase in stored energy.

- I got to the right conclusion that increasing R by 15% without changing y would produce the greater increase in stored energy I just used the logic of I=mr^2 and r=R+y so is R is bigger increasing R would obviously do more.

-However the mark scheme says:

(I = 2 mr2 and Ek = ½ I ω2)

Increasing y by 15% gives new I = 1.15^2 × original I (or 1.32) ✔

Increasing R by 15% increases I by 1.15^3 (or 1.52) ✔

Second option gives greater increase in I, and Ek

also increased (by same ratio). ✔

Accept answers without calculation:

I prop to y^2 ✔

I prop to R^3 ✔

I don't understand how they got

>I prop to y^2 ✔

>I prop to R^3 ✔

Moment of inertia is proportional to y^2 because they are just using I = mr^2 where r = y.

Next, the moment of inertia is proportional to R^3 is shown in the MS below. pay attention to the highlighted portion in yellow with a marking circled in red.

Post the whole MS in future and don’t assume the “trivial” info.

I disagree with their agreement if you study moment of inertia at University, you would know why. I guess they are simplifying the calculation to suit A level physics.

Original post by Eimmanuel

Moment of inertia is proportional to y^2 because they are just using I = mr^2 where r = y.

Next, the moment of inertia is proportional to R^3 is shown in the MS below. pay attention to the highlighted portion in yellow with a marking circled in red.

Post the whole MS in future and don’t assume the “trivial” info.

I disagree with their agreement if you study moment of inertia at University, you would know why. I guess they are simplifying the calculation to suit A level physics.

Next, the moment of inertia is proportional to R^3 is shown in the MS below. pay attention to the highlighted portion in yellow with a marking circled in red.

Post the whole MS in future and don’t assume the “trivial” info.

I disagree with their agreement if you study moment of inertia at University, you would know why. I guess they are simplifying the calculation to suit A level physics.

- University Application - Cambridge, Imperial, UCL, Manchester, Eidngurgh
- Scared I won’t get into uni
- Anyone else joining electronic and electrical engineering with foundation year?
- I’m stuck with what to do for A level
- Should i have a go at an A Level in maths when my current Mock grade is a Low 4/C?
- Subject Options + Overall
- 2023 Engineering applicants
- Alevel options
- retaking a levels
- A level choices
- Is a post-A level application for Oxford a good idea?
- How To Get An Oxford Engineering Offer: Chapter 3 - Super-curricular and Resources
- No level 3s and trying to find a way into Engineering as a 23 year old.
- Is the physics in an Engineering degree much harder than A Level physics?
- Official Aeronautical and Aerospace Engineering Applicants Thread 2021
- civil engineering
- 2024 Engineering Applicants
- UCL civil engineering
- Sheffield vs Leeds vs Cardiff vs Bath vs Nottingham
- Architecture and structural engineering

Last reply 1 minute ago

Inlaks, Commonwealth, and Other Scholarships for Indian Students 2024: ThreadLast reply 7 minutes ago

Can someone please mark my AIC essay (my teacher is such an unreliable marker)Last reply 14 minutes ago

Amazon Apprenticeships 2024Last reply 19 minutes ago

JK Rowling in ‘arrest me’ challenge over hate crime lawLast reply 25 minutes ago

Official Dental Hygiene and Therapy (Oral Health Science) 2024 Entry ThreadDentistry

2854

Last reply 29 minutes ago

Official: University of Birmingham A100 2024 Entry ApplicantsMedical Schools

1036

Last reply 35 minutes ago

Official London School of Economics and Political Science 2024 Applicant ThreadLast reply 40 minutes ago

UAL Bsc Fashion Management and fashion marketingLast reply 43 minutes ago

Can I do medicine with these gcse grades and what unis would be most likely to acceptLast reply 44 minutes ago

Official: Aston University A100 2024 Entry Applicant threadMedical Schools

1127

Last reply 46 minutes ago

Official University of Bristol Applicant Thread for 2024Posted 52 minutes ago

Can someone please mark this out of 30(all my teachers refused)