The Student Room Group

Please help...General question

x2+402\sqrt{x^2+40^2} the same as x+40?{x+40}? I dont think it is the same, but i dont understand why it is not the same.

@Pangol @RDKGames @Notnek
(edited 6 years ago)
Reply 1
Original post by Dexter212
x2+402\sqrt{x^2+40^2} the same as x+40?{x+40}? I dont think it is the same, but i dont understand why it is not the same.

@Pangol @RDKGames @Notnek

You're right they're not the same.

If they were the same then (x+40)2=x2+402(x+40)^2 = x^2+40^2. Can you see why this is false?

There is no law for A+B\sqrt{A+B} like there is for AB=A×B\sqrt{AB} = \sqrt{A}\times \sqrt{B} for example.
Reply 2
Original post by Dexter212
x2+402\sqrt{x^2+40^2} the same as x+40?{x+40}? I dont think it is the same, but i dont understand why it is not the same.

@Pangol @RDKGames @Notnek


It's not the same, no. The easiest way to see this is to say that if they were equal, you would get the same thing if you squared both of them. If you square the first version, you get x^2 + 40^2. What do you get if you square x + 40 ?
You have to work out what’s under the square root first, hence some people put brackets under square root signs. Take root(4+9) as an example. By your logic it would give 2+3 which equals 5. In reality it’s asking for root(13) which is a surd...
Reply 4
Original post by Notnek
If they were the same then (x+40)2=x2+402(x+40)^2 = x^2+40^2. Can you see why this is false?


Great minds...
Reply 5
Original post by Pangol
Great minds...

...do maths.
I suggest putting in some simple numbers. This can help you see that they are not the same:

32+42=9+16=25=5\sqrt{3^2+4^2} = \sqrt{9+16} = \sqrt{25} = 5

However:

3+4=7 3 + 4 = 7

5 and 7 are different, so this proves that they are not the same.
Original post by Notnek
You're right they're not the same.

If they were the same then (x+40)2=x2+402(x+40)^2 = x^2+40^2. Can you see why this is false?

There is no law for A+B\sqrt{A+B} like there is for AB=A×B\sqrt{AB} = \sqrt{A}\times \sqrt{B} for example.


So...
x2+402\sqrt{x^2+40^2} is not equal to x2+1600\sqrt{x^2}+\sqrt{1600} ?
Reply 8
Original post by joyoustele
So...
x2+402\sqrt{x^2+40^2} is not equal to x2+1600\sqrt{x^2}+\sqrt{1600} ?

Correct.
Original post by Notnek
Correct.


Got it, Thanks all. :smile:
Reply 10
Original post by joyoustele
Got it, Thanks all. :smile:

Are you the OP?
Original post by Notnek
Are you the OP?


Yes.:smile:
Reply 12
Original post by joyoustele
Yes.:smile:

Please try to stick to one account so people don't get confused :smile:
Original post by Notnek
Please try to stick to one account so people don't get confused :smile:


Okay

Quick Reply

Latest