The Student Room Group

Footballer or Footballer - This or That type

Scroll to see replies

Park.

Van Nistelrooy (prime) or Van Persie?
RVP is better right now than RVN ever was, but over the course of their careers, RVN was miles ahead(mainly because he didnt miss half seasons every year...). From a technical view point, obviously RVN wasnt up to RVP's level but he was more consistent and dependable. RVN's goal record was unbelievable tbh. RVN also has a much much better for Holland, and in the Eredivisie whilst also performing very well in Spain for Real Madrid. So RVN.

Van Bommel or Gilberto Silva?
(edited 10 years ago)
Almost forgot who Gilberto Silva was.
Easily Van Bommel. Legendary.

Owen (Prime)or Torres? (Prime)
Reply 4623
Original post by xxxKINGxxx
Almost forgot who Gilberto Silva was.
Easily Van Bommel. Legendary.

Owen (Prime)or Torres? (Prime)


At Liverpool Owen but in terms of overall ability Torres

Vieira or Makelele?
(edited 10 years ago)
Reply 4624
Makelele

Dani Alves or Ashley Cole?
Alves going forward but Cole defensively...

Alves overall

Marco Reus or Thomas Mueller
Reply 4626
Original post by munazic483
Alves going forward but Cole defensively...

Alves overall

Marco Reus or Thomas Mueller


Reus.
Javier Zanetti or Pavel Nedved?
Pavel Nedved.

Maloney or Brunt?
Original post by CJG21
Pavel Nedved.

Maloney or Brunt?


Maloney because I hope my team sign him:L Probably too expensive though, but I suppose he's getting on in age, relatively speaking.

Xabi Alonso or Javi Martinez?
Alonso, his amazing goals swayed it a bit! :mmm:

Tim Krul or Michel Vorm?
Krul

In their primes, Ferdinand or Terry?
Reply 4631
Original post by The Assassin
Krul

In their primes, Ferdinand or Terry?




Ferdinand for me. :holmes:

Zola or Cazorla? :beard:
Original post by Abiraleft
Ferdinand for me. :holmes:

Zola or Cazorla? :beard:


Definitely Zola.

Lavezzi or Navas?
Reply 4633
Original post by Chris-69
Definitely Zola.

Lavezzi or Navas?


Lavezzi.

David Silva or Juan Mata?

Posted from TSR Mobile
Mata, more direct and scores more goals.

Kyle Walker or Glen Johnson?
Reply 4635
Walker

Aaron Ramsey or Ashley Westwood?
Original post by Aust1n
Walker

Aaron Ramsey or Ashley Westwood?


Aaron Ramsey by a bit

Draxler or Chamberlain

Posted from TSR Mobile
Chamberlain, close though

Keown or Carragher?
Keown (in his prime of course! :mmm:)

Lampard or Gerrard? (now)
Reply 4639
Lampard now. He seems to be scoring more even though he is hardly playing and isn't being niggled by injuries. It was also him who helped Chelsea beat Barca last year. Overall I think he has aged better.

Clyne or Caulker?

Quick Reply

Latest