"there's husandry in heaven quote" - Banquo

Does anyone have a really good, grade 9 analysis they could share of the Banquo quote...

"There's husbandry in heaven; Their candles are all out. "

..including possible alternatives?

In Act 2, Scene 1 of Shakespeare's play Macbeth, the protagonist has just murdered King Duncan and is overcome with guilt and fear. As he stumbles out of the King's chamber, he utters the cryptic line "There's husbandry in heaven; Their candles are all out." This line reveals Macbeth's disturbed state of mind and foreshadows the chaos that is to come. The word "husbandry" also suggests that there is order and control in heaven, but the phrase "Their candles are all out" suggests the opposite. The image of the extinguished candles evokes a sense of darkness and loss, implying that the natural order has been disrupted. Macbeth's guilt has disrupted his sense of order and control, causing him to see chaos and disorder even in the heavens. This line also foreshadows the events that will follow Macbeth's murder of Duncan, as the natural order of the world is further disrupted by his subsequent actions. In this way, Shakespeare uses language to convey the psychological turmoil of his protagonist and to foreshadow the tragic events that are to come.

Another possible interpretation of the line "There's husbandry in heaven; Their candles are all out" could be that Macbeth is acknowledging the supernatural forces at work in the world, and that heaven itself is taking part in the chaos and destruction unfolding around him. The phrase "there's husbandry in heaven" could be interpreted as meaning that there is careful management or control of the events happening on earth, and that these events are orchestrated by a higher power. The line "their candles are all out" could be seen as a reference to the stars, which were often described as celestial candles in Shakespeare's time. Macbeth may be suggesting that the stars have gone out or are no longer shining.

Wow, thank you so much, very helpfull!!

No worries! I did a really intense series of essays on Macbeth before so this was really accessible 😌

In Act 2, Scene 1 of Shakespeare's play Macbeth, the protagonist has just murdered King Duncan and is overcome with guilt and fear. As he stumbles out of the King's chamber, he utters the cryptic line "There's husbandry in heaven; Their candles are all out." This line reveals Macbeth's disturbed state of mind and foreshadows the chaos that is to come. The word "husbandry" also suggests that there is order and control in heaven, but the phrase "Their candles are all out" suggests the opposite. The image of the extinguished candles evokes a sense of darkness and loss, implying that the natural order has been disrupted. Macbeth's guilt has disrupted his sense of order and control, causing him to see chaos and disorder even in the heavens. This line also foreshadows the events that will follow Macbeth's murder of Duncan, as the natural order of the world is further disrupted by his subsequent actions. In this way, Shakespeare uses language to convey the psychological turmoil of his protagonist and to foreshadow the tragic events that are to come.

Another possible interpretation of the line "There's husbandry in heaven; Their candles are all out" could be that Macbeth is acknowledging the supernatural forces at work in the world, and that heaven itself is taking part in the chaos and destruction unfolding around him. The phrase "there's husbandry in heaven" could be interpreted as meaning that there is careful management or control of the events happening on earth, and that these events are orchestrated by a higher power. The line "their candles are all out" could be seen as a reference to the stars, which were often described as celestial candles in Shakespeare's time. Macbeth may be suggesting that the stars have gone out or are no longer shining.

Sorry I've just realised, isn't it Banquo who says the lines "There's husbandry in heaven; Their candles are all out."??

Have you done your GCSE's?

In Act 2, Scene 1 of Shakespeare's play Macbeth, the protagonist has just murdered King Duncan and is overcome with guilt and fear. As he stumbles out of the King's chamber, he utters the cryptic line "There's husbandry in heaven; Their candles are all out." This line reveals Macbeth's disturbed state of mind and foreshadows the chaos that is to come. The word "husbandry" also suggests that there is order and control in heaven, but the phrase "Their candles are all out" suggests the opposite. The image of the extinguished candles evokes a sense of darkness and loss, implying that the natural order has been disrupted. Macbeth's guilt has disrupted his sense of order and control, causing him to see chaos and disorder even in the heavens. This line also foreshadows the events that will follow Macbeth's murder of Duncan, as the natural order of the world is further disrupted by his subsequent actions. In this way, Shakespeare uses language to convey the psychological turmoil of his protagonist and to foreshadow the tragic events that are to come.

Another possible interpretation of the line "There's husbandry in heaven; Their candles are all out" could be that Macbeth is acknowledging the supernatural forces at work in the world, and that heaven itself is taking part in the chaos and destruction unfolding around him. The phrase "there's husbandry in heaven" could be interpreted as meaning that there is careful management or control of the events happening on earth, and that these events are orchestrated by a higher power. The line "their candles are all out" could be seen as a reference to the stars, which were often described as celestial candles in Shakespeare's time. Macbeth may be suggesting that the stars have gone out or are no longer shining.