Messi is the better player but people can't **** on Ronaldo because of his performance at the world cup. He is in a team that has a few good players and a bunch of mediocre players. Messi was in a hilariously easy group and Argentina is much better than Portugal on paper. In addition, it was quite obvious that Ronaldo was not at his best at this world cup due to injuries. I for one think that looking at the world cup to compare great players is ridiculous given the amount of luck that is involved. More importantly, it is ridiculous to compare players on the basis of their comparative performance in the world cup when the teams players play for differ in quality. The champions league has better competition than the world cup, and Ronaldo scored 17 goals in that. Do people claim that this makes Ronaldo greater than Messi? Not if they have any sense. International trophies, or club trophies for that matter, don't determine a players greatness in my opinion because football isn't about one player. Regardless of what people say, Maradona didn't win the world cup on his own. Nobody ever could. If Messi played for Fiji, would they win the world cup?
I judge players almost exclusively on the eye test and on individual performances rather than team accolades. On that basis Messi>Ronaldo but they are both two of the greatest players of all time. In fact, I rate Messi as the best player of all time and don't think he needs the world cup to prove that. I hate the stupid world cup argument.
To everyone who uses the world cup argument, I'd like your opinion on the following statement. Brazilian Ronaldo sucks. He never won the Champions league, which takes place every year, despite being involved in the competition for more than a decade playing for some of the greatest three football clubs of all time in Inter Milan, Madrid and Barcelona. See how stupid that statement sounds?
I don't rate Suarez as being worse than Rooney because he hasn't won as many PL titles or the champions league because I know that if he played in the same teams he would have won the same accolades. The eye test tells me all I need to know. The sooner people understand that trophies are not an accurate measure of how good a player is individually the better.