Think some of the criticism levelled at Welbeck comes from failing to understand what his M.O. is really. He'll run all day long, presses very well, is physically strong, can run the channels and likes a big game too. If you expect him to be a ruthless finisher or good at linking up then of course you're going to be disappointed. His goal at OT looked like just luck but that comes from chasing lost causes and Welbeck did that. But of course he's not good enough to play ST for us at all and we should look to bring in someone soon.
Fergie always loved him and trusted him in big games so that's a decent reference imo. We've lacked players like that as I said. How many times have we gone down to sides full or Park ji-Sungs or Rameires types? It's good to have someone like Welbeck.