Today, we hear of the inclusivity of less intelligent children and those with special educational needs being championed in a ‘no child left behind’-esque manner. While the formerly oppressed and, for the most part, wrongly labelled ‘naughty’ children have become the focus of classroom support and praise, it’s clearly overlooked that there is an opportunity cost associated. Teachers aren’t given more time to support lower ability kids, they have to do more with the same amount of time, which is impossible and wholly unrealistic. Something has to give and it’s usually the encouragement and development of the ‘smart ones’.
The rise of ‘encouraging participation’ in certain activities and a ‘you’re all winners’ attitude simply belittles high-flying students’ achievements. Some intelligent children may not need to work as hard as those who are less academically inclined, but this does not mean they don’t deserve praise or as much attention. It’s perfectly possible for a child to be intelligent, not have to plough into work and still feel at a loss with confidence and self-belief. I massively believe that part of the lack of motivation in some bright children for revision etc is due to a lack of attention and push to be driven and career-minded from early education, especially through years 7 and 8.
The language we use when speaking to these kinds of children is incredibly ignorant. ‘You’ve got nothing to worry about’, ‘there are people in far worse positions than you’ and ‘you’re smart, you will go far’ all imply that you’re not a priority and you’ll be pushed aside, while the lesser able kids are told they’ll be supported to get them to where they need to be, or that it won’t be easy but they believe in them. Being astute is actually almost glamorised as the holy grail. You’re supposed to be eternally grateful that you’ve been ‘gifted’. It’s clear some have trouble seeing beyond surface intelligence and assume they’ll be fine because their brain will ‘never fail’ them.
It’s time to start normalising being smart again. Comments from other students such as ‘but how do you know that, why are you so smart, stop pushing it in our faces’ can make bright children feel like freaks and cause social exclusion. Being smart is natural. It’s time to stop making them feel like they’re incredibly lucky, as many kids also see it as a burden. The ‘too smart to fail’ puts unnecessary pressure on kids to either perform highly every time or fail and risk humiliation. Success and failure is natural in students of all abilities, and it’s time to stop the teachers', seemingly innocent, jokes and students’, well intentioned, questions about where intelligence comes from. Praise kids when they do well and support them when they don’t, regardless of ability.