Girls: Who is more attractive? Hipster Geek vs Athleticism

You told me to "note the design and style of the clothes" which identifies a hipster. Are you telling me that any checkered or plain shirt makes you a hipster? What is this magical style of shirt which makes you a hipster?

All you're doing is making an outrageous claim that anyone who has (facial) hair vaguely considered messy and wears a certain style of glasses is automatically a hipster. This in itself is a stupid and small minded claim because you are basing it on two factors - hair and glasses. Oh wait, is it three factors, with the addition of the style of a shirt, which you haven't explained at all...?

So you don't know what a hipster is, yet are going to argue about what makes you one....Right, because that is not bat**** crazy logic




Fashion is based on how you look. Those features...determines how he looks I know, crazy right?
Why are you trying to make out that his clothes determine what he is like deep down inside his soul and crap when this is about simple fashion?

No, "hipster" is an attitude. You are a hipster if you intentionally snub "the mainstream", even where you actually like the styles in the mainstream, in order to try and look edgy/ edgily retro/ silly in an I-don't-care-that-I-look-silly-I'm-making-a-statement manner. If you wear a beard or shirt because you think that they're not generally considered cool, but want to look cool by not caring that they're not cool, you're a hipster. On the other hand, if you just think, "oh, that's a nice shirt, I think I might wear that", you don't become a hipster by wearing it.

I can't remember the last time I saw a Goth at a tea party, but this thread is talking about the image.

So you don't know what a hipster is, yet are going to argue about what makes you one....Right, because that is not bat**** crazy logic

Why are you trying to make out that his clothes determine what he is like deep down inside his soul and crap when this is about simple fashion?

You're the one who's saying that JT looks like a hipster in those photos. I'm the one saying that he doesn't look like one because wearing a shirt and glasses does not make you a hipster. It's a stupid assumption people make.

You keep telling me to note the style, but how does JT's shirt choice make him a hipster...? There is no style of shirt which singularly makes you a hipster because it does not exist. You still haven't told me what style of shirt makes you a hipster, cos it does not exist.

A hipster, fashion-wise, is someone who wears vintage clothes which are particularly outlandish and unique, thus making them veer away from the 'mainstream'. What is so ridiculously outlandish about a shirt and glasses...? It just happens to be that the Wayfarer-esque frames were popularised by actual hipsters who wore them whether they needed them or not. Just cos you wear the frames it does not automatically make you a hipster. You're also forgetting that being a hipster is also about independent thinking, appreciating art and indie music, and all that jazz. Girls who wear the 'hipster' glasses and dress like idiots are, surprise, surprise, ****ing idiots, who know nothing about being actual hipsters. The whole subculture has spiralled out of control.



When did I ever do such a thing? I'm the one telling you that he is not a hipster... You're the one making that assumption because you are telling me that he is a hipster.

OP doesn't know what a hipster is; he's just following that same assumption that anyone who wears glasses is a hipster, like you. Oh, I can't forget the shirts though, that special, non-existent style of shirts which makes you a hipster.

JT is not a hipster in those photos.

If only

Obviously intelligence is one of the main factors in attraction, both for genetic and purely preferential reasons. However, geeks aren't always smart, and not all smart people are geeks, by a long way. Also, the word geek has nothing to do with good looking men who happen to wear glasses with those rims - also the clothes are really unpleasant in my opinion (OP's pictures).

One thing that bugs me is (girls normally...) going 'omg playing cod... such a geek lol!)

I find it funny how some guys are calling the girls who don't like super athletic types ugly or insecure. So much for them having self-esteem.

Just as the females are 'programmed' to be attracted to the athletic types the males are programmed to like women who carry weight, have wide hips, and full breasts because they are considered good traits for bearing, and feeding babies.
But you guys won't prefer over would you?

It's similar for us girls. An athletic figure is sexy, but there is a limit to how much muscle most girls like. I, personally find super buff guys disgusting. All that muscle looks very very unnatural.

This is always funny to me as someone who ACTUALLY plays games and not just call of duty, I'm not sure why girls think its a great to attract attention by saying they play cod and zelda haha..., but this picture pretty much sums it up, the first girl in that picture is what you're referring too

This is always funny to me as someone who ACTUALLY plays games and not just call of duty, I'm not sure why girls think its a great to attract attention by saying they play cod and zelda haha..., but this picture pretty much sums it up, the first girl in that picture is what you're referring too