People who can speak French fluently should not take A level French

Or any language for that matter. It's extremely unfair for someone who actually wants to learn and acquire the language to compete against someone who can basically already speak it. It seems grade boundaries are constantly raised by people who lived in France for 8 years/have a parent who is fluent in French and only take the subject for the A*. I imagine it's probably the same difficulty as an English speaker taking English Language GCSE if not easier.

Or any language for that matter. It's extremely unfair for someone who actually wants to learn and acquire the language to compete against someone who can basically already speak it. It seems grade boundaries are constantly raised by people who lived in France for 8 years/have a parent who is fluent in French and only take the subject for the A*. I imagine it's probably the same difficulty as an English speaker taking English Language GCSE if not easier.

I agree with you! If you're a native speaker or already fluent then there's no point in taking your own language at A level because you won't learn anything new or achieve anything. I'm English but got a C in A level German and an A in GCSE German. A level German was difficult.

Or any language for that matter. It's extremely unfair for someone who actually wants to learn and acquire the language to compete against someone who can basically already speak it. It seems grade boundaries are constantly raised by people who lived in France for 8 years/have a parent who is fluent in French and only take the subject for the A*. I imagine it's probably the same difficulty as an English speaker taking English Language GCSE if not easier.

While I agree, think of it from their perspective.

They'll get an easy A Level at presumably an A/A*, so why wouldn't they?

That grade will probably help them secure a good university offer, so I know if I could speak a foreign language fluently and had the opportunity to do it as an A Level, I would, because it's easy marks, despite it not being fair for everyone else.

Or any language for that matter. It's extremely unfair for someone who actually wants to learn and acquire the language to compete against someone who can basically already speak it. It seems grade boundaries are constantly raised by people who lived in France for 8 years/have a parent who is fluent in French and only take the subject for the A*. I imagine it's probably the same difficulty as an English speaker taking English Language GCSE if not easier.

Or any language for that matter. It's extremely unfair for someone who actually wants to learn and acquire the language to compete against someone who can basically already speak it. It seems grade boundaries are constantly raised by people who lived in France for 8 years/have a parent who is fluent in French and only take the subject for the A*. I imagine it's probably the same difficulty as an English speaker taking English Language GCSE if not easier.

Hello,

I completely disagree with you - and I study French at degree level in Paris. Native speakers should be allowed to capitalise on it if they want to do so - you can still learn things as a native from studying your own language, for example, complicated grammar etc. (ones which you may use, but do not know the theory behind). As Planta says above, it's going to make no difference to you anyway - so why do you care?

It's not remotely 'extremely unfair'. By this logic, you should immediately stop studying English because you can already speak it and it's unfair to other people that aren't English that want to study it. Which of course, is total nonsense. If they want the A* then why not? They're simply utilising their skills. If somebody was a Maths prodigy from a young age and had incredible skills in the subject, they would obviously take Maths A-level and there'd be no problem with that, despite the two situations being relatively comparable.

You can't compare French A level to English A level. French is very much revolved around learning the language (granted, much of this is difficult if you are not a native speaker) and much less around analysing techniques/themes etc. which English is mostly.

people who are naturally gifted in maths should be banned from A level maths because it is unfair the others.

people who are naturally gifted in maths should be banned from A level maths because it is unfair the others.

What a ridiculous comparison. There is no such thing as being 'naturally gifted' in a language, you are just lucky to have grown up in a foreign country/have a fluent parent. If you are naturally gifted in a certain subject, good for you. The difference with A level French is that regular students are at a huge disadvantage against fluent speakers - they have had so much more experience in the subject, and I'm pretty sure the point of A level MFL is to learn a language in detail rather than just regurgitate something that you've been comfortable with since you were a child.

French A-level actually combines both of these things. Language more so, yes, but to say that it's "revolved" around language is inaccurate. What I'm saying is that you sound jealous and bitter and should instead focus on getting your grades rather than being envious of your French-speaking peers. They're studying their language in English - which is a feat in itself. Either way, it simply doesn't matter.