The Student Room Group

I’ve Completed a Degree Apprenticeship, Ask Me Anything!

I’ve completed 4 apprenticeships in engineering:
Intermediate (L2), advanced (L3), higher (L4-L5), and degree (L6).

Happy to answer any questions you might have about education, work, training, development, work-life balance, challenges etc.

Scroll to see replies

do you think the path you took is better than going to uni full time?
what part of engeineering?
Reply 2
Original post by Gent2324
do you think the path you took is better than going to uni full time?
what part of engeineering?

My degree apprenticeship was mechanical engineering, working within medical device research and development.

In summary, yes, for me personally my apprenticeship was the better option.

To save giving you a very broad reply, would you be able to expand on the question please?
(edited 3 years ago)
Original post by Chris2892
I’m summary, yes, for me personally.
To save giving you a very broad reply, would you be able to expand on the question please?

do you think the path you took is better than going to uni full time in terms of promotions, salary, ability to find other jobs and difficulty in the work
I've always thought that degree apprenticeships are a better option. I'm just finishing up a degree in education, which entailed only 14 days on placement.... I still lack the confidence required to teach and the attitude was "sink of swim" in the sense that if you didn't grasp it or felt uncomfortable there was very little support available....
Reply 5
Original post by Gent2324
do you think the path you took is better than going to uni full time in terms of promotions, salary, ability to find other jobs and difficulty in the work

The apprenticeship setting provides opportunity not only to improve academic skills, but also task management and interpersonal skills with meaningful and progressive feedback. Both I feel require improvement in university courses.

In addition, the apprenticeship off-the-job training hour requirements mean a substantial amount of additional training is provided to apprentices. Where at university my project management module was assessed by a multiple choice exam, my project management training at work was certified by my ability to develop a solid project plan and effective risk mitigation. The final assessment being my ability to meet the deliverables and quantified project objectives. This was for a real world research project that eventually gained me a publication.

The work is extremely difficult and you’re always progressively pushed to improve, but with a huge support network. However, the work is meaningful and often with lasting effect. This drove me to perform through satisfaction that what I did was making a difference in the workplace.

So yes, I strongly believe that the apprenticeship route is more successful in developing a well-rounded engineer. Which in turn would be more desirable to employers.
(edited 3 years ago)
Original post by Chris2892
The apprenticeship setting provides opportunity not only to improve academic skills, but also task management and interpersonal skills with meaningful and progressive feedback. Both I feel require improvement in university courses.

In addition, the apprenticeship off-the-job training hour requirements mean a substantial amount of additional training is provided to apprentices. Where at university my project management module was assessed by a multiple choice exam, my project management training at work was certified by my ability to develop a solid project plan and effective risk mitigation. The final assessment being my ability to meet the deliverables and quantified project objectives. This was for a real world research project that eventually gained me a publication.

The work is extremely difficult and you’re always progressively pushed to improve, but with a huge support network. However, the work is meaningful and often with lasting effect. This drove me to perform through satisfaction that what I did was making a difference in the workplace.

So yes, I strongly believe that the apprenticeship route is more successful in developing a well-rounded engineer. Which in turn would be more desirable to employers.

Couldn't have put it better myself, imho degree apprenticeships should be a thing in more industries.
Hey, thanks for starting this thread. Degree apprenticeships still seem to be overlooked.

Is the route to chartership more difficult?

Also, how does the transition from degree to full-time work happen? Do you automatically get offered a job with the company you're being an apprentice with? How do you feel about your future career prospects?

Trying to get a feel for how the professional life is different
(edited 3 years ago)
Reply 8
Original post by SpiceRice
Hey, thanks for starting this thread. Degree apprenticeships still seem to be overlooked.

Is the route to chartership more difficult?

Also, how does the transition from degree to full-time work happen? Do you automatically get offered a job with the company you're being an apprentice with? How do you feel about your future career prospects?

Trying to get a feel for how the professional life is different

The new apprenticeship framework has replaced the National Vocation Qualification (NVQ) with an End Point Assessment (EPA).

The EPA external assessment requires the apprenticeship to evidence their competence by a summary 4K word report, ~3 hour presentation, and a professional discussion. This is in reference to specific knowledge, behavioural, and skills detailed in the apprenticeship framework. The EPA evidencing is very similar to what would be required in applying for Incorporated (IEng) or Chartered Engineer (CEng).

I’d argue that because the evidence gathering is compulsory for the completion of an apprenticeship, a IEng or CEng application is much easier to submit and obtain because you already have the evidence gathered by the time you finish your university studies.

As for careers, this is dependent on the employer. My prospects were very broad, I was offered the option to do a full-time fully funded PhD without having to complete an MEng with a Russel Group university. I’ve instead decided to continue working for my employer, who have shown interest in funding a part-time PhD with successful submission of a business-need related research proposal.
(edited 3 years ago)
Original post by Chris2892
The new apprenticeship framework has replaced the National Vocation Qualification (NVQ) with an End Point Assessment (EPA).

The EPA external assessment requires the apprenticeship to evidence their competence by a summary 4K word report, ~3 hour presentation, and a professional discussion. This is in reference to specific knowledge, behavioural, and skills detailed in the apprenticeship framework. The EPA evidencing is very similar to what would be required in applying for Incorporated (IEng) or Chartered Engineer (CEng).

I’d argue that because the evidence gathering is compulsory for the completion of an apprenticeship, a IEng or CEng application is much easier to submit and obtain because you already have the evidence gathered by the time you finish your university studies.

As for careers, this is dependent on the employer. My prospects were very broad, I was offered the option to do a full-time fully funded PhD without having to complete an MEng with a Russel Group university. I’ve instead decided to continue working for my employer, who have shown interest in funding a part-time PhD with successful submission of a business-need related research proposal.

3 hour presentation?!?! :s-smilie:
That's definitely interesting to hear re EPA. I've already started my eee degree so can't reconsider now, but I'll try to pass on the info to people I know.

How much freedom did you have in deciding what to specialise in? Did you know you wanted to work in medical device research?
Your field of work sounds interesting actually, wonder if you could possibly describe what your role is
Reply 10
Original post by SpiceRice
3 hour presentation?!?! :s-smilie:
That's definitely interesting to hear re EPA. I've already started my eee degree so can't reconsider now, but I'll try to pass on the info to people I know.

How much freedom did you have in deciding what to specialise in? Did you know you wanted to work in medical device research?
Your field of work sounds interesting actually, wonder if you could possibly describe what your role is

I didn’t particularly enjoy presenting either when I started, but I got used to it. There’s not really any other choice for some situations. The EPA can be 1-to-1 with an external assessor, so no stress of crowds. You talk about 4 or more separate projects in detail and explain the what’s, how’s, and why’s. So you can see how this might take a while, but it doesn’t have to be 3 hours. I wouldn’t worry about it yet, but you can begin keeping a log of the work you do etc.

I didn’t have much freedom of choice in the first 3 years, I rotated every 6 month around pre arranged departments and did all sorts of different projects. The rotations then switched to a year in length, but I chose to stay in my current department for the final 2 years.

I did my L2 and L3 in diesel engineering, and started to see it wasn’t likely to be a long term career. I saw the degree apprenticeship job opening and did some research. It just stood out for me. I didn’t really know the industry existed until I saw the opening.

I’ve done rotations within the product verification teams in both Tribology and Biomechanics, and also commercialised product design, process quality, and design quality. My current role is mainly verifying hip replacement design inputs by simulation of representative use, using both electro-mechanical and computational types of simulation. It’s really challenging and interesting, I love it.
(edited 3 years ago)
Hi, I am considering doing an EPQ which is a written research project where you write 5000 words about a certain topic. If I do go ahead with it, my topic will be something along the lines of engineering/ sustainability, do you think this will benefit a degree apprenticeship application?? Thanks in advance
Reply 12
Original post by burntspark
Hi, I am considering doing an EPQ which is a written research project where you write 5000 words about a certain topic. If I do go ahead with it, my topic will be something along the lines of engineering/ sustainability, do you think this will benefit a degree apprenticeship application?? Thanks in advance

Absolutely!
Many companies have sustainability initiatives around reducing waste and carbon emissions. In fact my own employer has a dedicated voluntary team who specifically propose site/process changes to improve sustainability.

Some of the initiatives include car sharing, alternative renewable power, cycle to work schemes, electric car charging ports etc.

Specific to engineering, many manufacturers are now looking towards 3D printing as a way to reduce stock material waste (renewable powder).
(edited 3 years ago)
Original post by Chris2892
Absolutely!
Many companies have sustainability initiatives around reducing waste and carbone emissions. In fact my own employer has a dedicated voluntary team who specifically propose site/process changes to improve sustainability.

Some of the initiatives include car sharing, alternative renewable power, cycle to work schemes, electric car charging ports etc.

Specific to engineering, many manufacturers are now looking towards 3D printing as a way to reduce stock material waste (renewable powder).


Hi Chris, thanks for this!!!! sounds brilliant, defiantly pushed towards doing it, seeing as you are in the field, do you know any other areas of engineering which are developing which i can maybe research? thanks for the tips
Reply 14
Original post by burntspark
Hi Chris, thanks for this!!!! sounds brilliant, defiantly pushed towards doing it, seeing as you are in the field, do you know any other areas of engineering which are developing which i can maybe research? thanks for the tips

I have two more examples where sustainability might be applied within engineering

Increased use of computational analysis and simulation to reduce physical testing and resource use. FEA and CFD simulation are relatively cheap in comparison to their physical counterparts.

Development of VR technology to improve and reduce the requirement of travelling large distances for meetings and training.

You should be able to find recent research discussing these subjects on sciencedirect.com.
Original post by Chris2892
I have two more examples where sustainability might be applied within engineering

Increased use of computational analysis and simulation to reduce physical testing and resource use. FEA and CFD simulation are relatively cheap in comparison to their physical counterparts.

Development of VR technology to improve and reduce the requirement of travelling large distances for meetings and training.

You should be able to find recent research discussing these subjects on sciencedirect.com.


Hi Chris, thanks for this, I'll defiantly check out science direct.
Reply 16
Original post by burntspark
Hi Chris, thanks for this, I'll defiantly check out science direct.

I’m assuming you’re not familiar with research writing if you’ve not come across science direct, but apologies if you are.

Science direct is like the bible for those undertaking research, individuals usually start with a comprehensive review of current and relevant literature.

You’ll find many papers are very specialised and difficult to follow without strong knowledge of the subject. You should however be able to find key sentences summarising background, method, and findings in the abstract.

Be sure to reference back to any research you quote so readers can fact check. Microsoft word has a reference function that lets you create a library of references and insert citations (in text references). I suggest you google how to use this.

Correct referencing and good research writing skills are an extremely good skill to learn early in your career. It’s something you can use to showcase your initiative and interest in interviews/applications, even if it’s just an attempt.
Reply 17
Hi, I'm taking a gap year and want to do a degree apprenticeship in civil engineering next year, I was just wondering if you had any advice on what I could do now to make me stand out in the application process/make me more likely to get a place. I've just got a part time job and I'm looking for work experience but haven't got any yet and as applications for apprenticeships start in Autumn I don't know if I'll get anything before then. Would online courses in Excel or AutoCAD etc be beneficial? I didn't do an EPQ at sixth form so would some sort of research project be a good thing to do? Do I need to know a lot about the industry to talk about at the interview eg from reading books and articles and watching documentaries etc? I don't know anyone who's done this and my school didn't help with apprentiecships so I don't know how to prepare or what the best thing to do is. I applied for one for this year a couple of months ago for practice, and I got past the online tests but they didn't invite me for an interview so I think there must be something wrong with my CV. I've played piano for eleven years and I've volunteered a bit before and now have a job, but nothing relevant to engineering. Is there anything you suggest I do, and do you know what they'll think of me taking a gap year? Do you think I'll be more likely to get a place because I've done my A levels and they know I already have the grades? (I'm taking a gap year because at the time of applications last year I didn't know what I wanted to do but now I do so I have to wait another year before starting). Thanks for any help, I know I've asked a lot of questions I just don't know what to do and I know they're really competitive and I don't want to go to university, so if I don't get one I don't know what I'll do.
Hi,

Im currently doing a level 4 Diploma (probably a completely lower level to what you've done) my question is (and im not sure if the wording is correct for the UK) did you have to do the whole gown and cap graduation when completing your course? I'm not totally sure if I've got too and I don't actually know anyone that's been to one either as a guest or the person graduating. Any information on the process would be great.

Thanks Alan.
Reply 19
Original post by Anon243
Hi, I'm taking a gap year and want to do a degree apprenticeship in civil engineering next year, I was just wondering if you had any advice on what I could do now to make me stand out in the application process/make me more likely to get a place. I've just got a part time job and I'm looking for work experience but haven't got any yet and as applications for apprenticeships start in Autumn I don't know if I'll get anything before then. Would online courses in Excel or AutoCAD etc be beneficial? I didn't do an EPQ at sixth form so would some sort of research project be a good thing to do? Do I need to know a lot about the industry to talk about at the interview eg from reading books and articles and watching documentaries etc? I don't know anyone who's done this and my school didn't help with apprentiecships so I don't know how to prepare or what the best thing to do is. I applied for one for this year a couple of months ago for practice, and I got past the online tests but they didn't invite me for an interview so I think there must be something wrong with my CV. I've played piano for eleven years and I've volunteered a bit before and now have a job, but nothing relevant to engineering. Is there anything you suggest I do, and do you know what they'll think of me taking a gap year? Do you think I'll be more likely to get a place because I've done my A levels and they know I already have the grades? (I'm taking a gap year because at the time of applications last year I didn't know what I wanted to do but now I do so I have to wait another year before starting). Thanks for any help, I know I've asked a lot of questions I just don't know what to do and I know they're really competitive and I don't want to go to university, so if I don't get one I don't know what I'll do.


Hey,
a degree apprenticeship includes part-time university study. A higher apprenticeship would maybe involve a HNC and HND at college, which leads to a BEng top-up.

In regards to finding an apprenticeship...
You need to have a mutual understanding with the employer and industry. Think of finding an apprenticeship employer like finding a friend. You want them to be excited and invested in the same discussion and hobbies that you are. You’d want them to be passionate about your interests. This in mind, make sure you’re very passionate about the role you’re applying for, you’ll need the motivation to get through the apprenticeship.

Demonstrating experience
Experience is great on a CV and all, but if you’re not able to express its significance or identify how skills are transferable, it’s not very useful even if it’s relevant. Everything in employment is held together by communication, and it’s important to learn how to convey the meaningful experience you’ve gained.

Things you can do
So to give you some conclusive advise, focus your time on understanding the experience you have, and your strengths.

Telling an employer you play piano to x level doesn’t inform them you’re a good piano player. It tells them you’re open to learning new skills, persistent, and self-motivated. I’d advise you to collate your experience and identify what skills you’ve gained.

my supervisor bought me Gallup’s strengths finder 2.0, which is a book with an online assessment for £14 on Amazon. It’s great for identifying what unique strengths you could bring to a team, irrespective of industry type.

hope this helps,
chris
(edited 3 years ago)

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending