The Student Room Group

Uganda Anti-Homosexuality bill: Ugandan President signs said bill into law

Scroll to see replies

Original post by Talkative Toad
What are your thoughts on the 2014 one then?

I think that this 2023 bill hasn't been fully drafted yet hence why it's not the Ugandan gov website.


i mean what is there to say. it's vile. you might need to ask me a more specific question.
Original post by Genesiss
i mean what is there to say. it's vile. you might need to ask me a more specific question.


Fair enough
Original post by WADR
What has "been going on in America" then? :hmmm:


In America and the West, homosexuality is no longer just something people do in the privacy of their bedrooms. It has now become a powerful activist movement that demands more than just tolerance, protection from discrimination and respect for human rights. It has begun to promote homosexuality in education, the media and other areas of the public sphere as a social norm, and it seeks to remove heteronormativity and the primacy of the traditional family unit from the culture and structure of society.

Contrast that with something like polyamory. This is also a lifestyle that people legally partake in, but it remains a largely personal matter. There's no significant push for polygamous marriages to be officially recognised by the state. We don't really see kids' books depicting families with three parents: a daddy and his two wives. Netflix and Disney aren't making it a point to casually include "throuples" in their shows. Most people wouldn't know what a "polyamory pride" flag looks like etc.
(edited 1 year ago)
Reply 63
Original post by tazarooni89
In America and the West, homosexuality has become more of a sociopolitical movement rather than just something people do in the privacy of their bedrooms. This movement has expanded beyond just asking for tolerance, protection from bullying and discrimination and the respecting of human rights. It is now promoting homosexuality in education, the media and other areas of the public sphere as a social norm, and seeking to remove heteronormativity from the culture and structure of society.

Contrast that with something like polyamory, which is still a lifestyle that people partake in (completely legally), but isn't having anywhere near the same social and cultural impact in the public sphere. Hardly anyone is calling for the state to officially recognise polygamous marriages. You don't really see kids' books making it a point to depict families with three parents: a daddy and his two wives. Netflix and Disney don't seem to be making it a point to casually include "throuples" in their shows. Hardly anyone knows what a polyamory pride flag looks like etc.

That's because polyamory is a bit embarassing, and also not a sexual orientation. I agree that it is good that homosexuality is becoming normalised.
Original post by Jingo7
That's because polyamory is a bit embarassing, and also not a sexual orientation.


Why would that make a difference? Homosexuality was once considered "embarrassing" as well.

Anyway the point is, Uganda isn't criminalising homosexuality per se. But it does seem to be trying to avoid the rise of a sociopolitical movement off the back of it.
I’ve been in regular contact with an Ugandan man who is gay and now thanks to this draconian bill I’m worried for his safety. Why people just can’t live and let live I have no idea
Reply 66
Original post by tazarooni89
Why would that make a difference? Homosexuality was once considered "embarrassing" as well.

Anyway the point is, Uganda isn't criminalising homosexuality per se. But it does seem to be trying to avoid the rise of a sociopolitical movement off the back of it.

Polyamory is just different, can't you see that?

Uganda is criminalising homosexuality, like, it just did. Are you ok?
Original post by Jingo7
Polyamory is just different, can't you see that?


Maybe if you'd care to elaborate?

Uganda is criminalising homosexuality, like, it just did.


To clarify: it is not a crime in Uganda to be attracted to members of the same sex.
(edited 1 year ago)
Reply 68
Original post by tazarooni89
Maybe if you'd care to elaborate?

Sure. Polyamory is a choice and therefore a 'lifestyle' (in your words). Homosexuality is not. As in, people don't choose it, it is just how their sexuality turned out.
Reply 69
Original post by tazarooni89
To clarify: it is not a crime in Uganda to be attracted to members of the same sex.

Well no, it is still impossible to arrest people for their thoughts and feeling.
Original post by Jingo7
Sure. Polyamory is a choice and therefore a 'lifestyle' (in your words). Homosexuality is not. As in, people don't choose it, it is just how their sexuality turned out.


Attraction to multiple people isn't a choice. Participation in a sexual relationship with multiple people is.
Similarly, even if attraction to a member of the same sex isn't a choice, participation in a sexual relationship with them is.

You haven't really pointed out what the difference is.
Reply 71
Original post by tazarooni89
Attraction to multiple people isn't a choice. Participation in a sexual relationship with multiple people is.
Similarly, even if attraction to a member of the same sex isn't a choice, participation in a sexual relationship with them is.

You haven't really pointed out what the difference is.

It isn't about how many people you're attracted to. Homosexuality is about the basic orientation of your desire itself, whether it's toward men or women.
Original post by Jingo7
It isn't about how many people you're attracted to. Homosexuality is about the basic orientation of your desire itself, whether it's toward men or women.


How does that make polyamory any more of a choice than homosexuality? It's still the case for both that, whilst the desire itself may not be a choice, engaging in the relationship is. Simply calling one a "basic orientation" and not the other doesn't really explain the difference; they're still both ultimately experienced as attraction to certain people, and both face the choice over whether to convert that into a relationship or not.

And more to the point: why does any of this mean that one should get a sociopolitical movement to normalise it and not the other?
(edited 1 year ago)
Damn, didn't know Ugandan's were so based

Spoiler

Original post by tazarooni89
Why would that make a difference? Homosexuality was once considered "embarrassing" as well.

Anyway the point is, Uganda isn't criminalising homosexuality per se. But it does seem to be trying to avoid the rise of a sociopolitical movement off the back of it.


Can't see how this bill does anything but criminalising homosexuality.

Life in prison for stating your gay or being persecuted for being gay is legit the dictionary definition of criminalising homosexuality.
Original post by Talkative Toad
Can't see how this bill does anything but criminalising homosexuality.

Life in prison for stating your gay or being persecuted for being gay is legit the dictionary definition of criminalising homosexuality.


Homosexuality means “attraction to members of the same sex”. It’s not a crime to be attracted to members of the same sex.

But yes, many of the subsequent things that might result from homosexuality are criminalised.
Original post by tazarooni89
Homosexuality means “attraction to members of the same sex”. It’s not a crime to be attracted to members of the same sex.

But yes, many of the subsequent things that might result from homosexuality are criminalised.


In Uganda it is a crime because of this bill, that's the simple point you're failing to understand here.

If you identify as gay or spread LGBTQ+ stuff or partake in Gay activity then you could face prison time or persecution, that's criminalising homosexuality 101. Hence why the statement "Uganda isn't criminalising homosexuality per se. " is false.

If Uganda wasn't trying to criminalise homosexuality then they'd be no need to have these bills and acts and people would be able to be openly gay in Uganda without fear of punishment from the state like you can here in the UK and USA.
Original post by Jingo7
Polyamory is just different, can't you see that?

Uganda is criminalising homosexuality, like, it just did. Are you ok?


Thinking the same thing.


Note this thread isn't about polygamy though.
Original post by Talkative Toad
If you identify as gay or spread LGBTQ stuff or partake in Gay activity then you could face prison time or persecution, that's criminalising homosexuality 101. Hence why the statement "Uganda isn't criminalising homosexuality per se. " is false.


“Homosexuality per se is simply being attracted to members of the same sex, which is not a crime.

Yes, other things you have mentioned are crimes: openly promoting homosexuality, spreading LGBTQ literature, and partaking in homosexual acts. But this is not “homosexuality per se”. These are things that a homosexual person may or may not do.
(edited 1 year ago)
Original post by tazarooni89
Homosexuality means “attraction to members of the same sex”. It’s not a crime to be attracted to members of the same sex.

But yes, many of the subsequent things that might result from homosexuality are criminalised.

Do you consider Uganda's laws against homosexuality to be wrong? Do you think they should be changed?

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending