This has got me really stumped - a lot different from the usual offer/acceptance nature of contract law.
Really struggling on this question, as are are a lot of people on my course, would appreciate if you have any idea on an approach here.
Patrick Nettlepatch is the majority shareholder in and managing director of PNT Ltd, which manufactures agricultural trailers. Capital Acquisitions plc (“CA”) wishes to acquire PNT.
Prior to the sale, Patrick explains to the managing director of CA, Derek Drivehard, that PNT is sited on very valuable land outside Norwich and is generally a very prosperous company. Derek agrees to pay £5 million pounds for PNT on the basis that this is a fair estimate of the value of PNT, but states that “this will need to be adjusted to reflect the true value in due course”.
Patrick and the remaining shareholders of PNT enter into a share sale agreement with CA under which:
• CA acquires immediate control of PNT;
• The vendor shareholders receive an initial payment of £5 million, which is said to represent an estimate of the net asset value of PNT;
• The parties agree to the preparation of post-completion accounts which will determine the net asset value of PNT at the time of the share sale;
• An upward adjustment will be made to the initial payment of £5 million if the net asset value of PNT is shown to exceed the value estimated at the time of completion;
• There is an ‘entire agreement’ clause limiting the parties’ rights to the contractual provisions set out in the agreement and excluding any other express or implied terms and any pre-contractual statements, which are to have no contractual or tortious effect; and
• There is no warranty by the vendors regarding the exact net asset value of PNT, as this was to be determined by reference to the post-completion accounts.
The post-completion accounts show that the net asset value of PNT is lower than Derek expected and that the price of £5 million represents a considerable overpayment. Derek would like to recoup some of the consideration paid by making a downward adjustment to the price. However, the share acquisition agreement only refers to upward adjustments to the price being made following the preparation of the post-completion accounts.
Prepare a memo of advice regarding Derek’s legal position.
thanks and regards.