Since I'm completely free of bias given I only post for educational/pseudo-philanthropic reasons I'll do a complete review of the posters I know.
Arsenal:
- Overmars was a really good poster, genuine shame he's gone
- RobbieC no content to speak of but he was funny at times
- Hubert cute poster but he didn't really have much to say
- Abiraleft is completely forgettable, I'm aware he posts but can't think of a single point he's ever made
- T Adams very under rated, he suffered from being too intelligent too, on a level people couldn't comprehend
- JK was decent but he treated the forum like a popularity contest, got in the way of proper posting
Liverpool:
- There's a bed of quite boring but knowledgeable posters here, I can't remember their names and they all hold boring opinions but they're sound at least- know their club
- Mess is terrible, he just paraphrases other posters and authors he's read
- Deshi I struggle to differentiate from Mess but I vaguely remember he's better
Chelsea:
- Christ these posters were bad, Jam is showing promise but I'll have to keep my eye on him, the girl who liked metal was god awful
- n1r4v used to post here a lot and he was good too
United:
- Kev is rarely wrong but needs to drop the idea that he's always right, it makes his posting awkward like the kid in the corner of a party sipping his pint petrified by rejection
- Whw is like a small child- cute but annoying
- River85 is very knowledgeable but incapable of comprehending an opposing point
- Mastermind I've just never got. Very average poster with little to say- is it because his name is purple?
- The guy with the Smiths as his picture was good, embarassed me a few times in the early days
Villa:
- These ones annoy me no end, its like a university comedy club society- everyone is trying to be funny but anyone remotely funny can see the hilarity of the place and steers well clear
Then there's the annoying English kids who pretend to support continental clubs and lecture people. If I wanted to know about it I'd read the same English authors you just did.
If I've missed anyone quote me and I'll review you too.