Year 12s: what will be the first way you research your future options? >>

This discussion is now closed.

Check out other Related discussions

The Israel/Palestine Conflict Mk. IV

Scroll to see replies

Reply 4840

Micah Richards

Original post by Snagprophet

Do you have an actual point?

That next time she come into a discussion armed with logic and morality, not 'I'm a descendant of a holocaust survivor therefore I am offended'.

Reply 4841

n00

Original post by Snagprophet

How is this a concentration camp? It's border control.

noun
noun: concentration camp; plural noun: concentration camps

a place in which large numbers of people, especially political prisoners or members of persecuted minorities, are deliberately imprisoned in a relatively small area with inadequate facilities, sometimes to provide forced labour or to await mass execution.

Reply 4842

broscience123

Original post by leahmshaya

It seems some people have misunderstood me. I did not mean to 'use' the Holocaust as a 'justification' for anything. I simply thought that the term concentration camp had been inappropriately used on this occasion and was a subversion of what Feiglin actually meant. Not that I agree with what he did mean. So I think you should all chill a bit.

Posted from TSR Mobile

Bro, seems like you are quite inexperienced at hasbara. You are meant to agree with everything that Zionists say and do. No matter how stupid or offensive they are, and no matter who or how many people are killed. Zionists are always right, and they need to be defended on the Interweb.

Reply 4843

tsr1269

UK's arms export licenses, worth $13 billion, is under review.

Reply 4844

Snagprophet

Original post by Micah Richards

That next time she come into a discussion armed with logic and morality, not 'I'm a descendant of a holocaust survivor therefore I am offended'.

She did though, she said she saw no evidence what the article claimed being linked to the facebook comments.

Original post by n00

So where is this happening in Israel?

Reply 4845

leahmshaya

Original post by n00

There was absolutely no mention of inadequate facilities or forced labour or mass execution. It is all a case of over dramatising a pretty standard (nevertheless unpleasant) piece of right wing rhetoric which will never actually happen.

Posted from TSR Mobile

Reply 4846

n00

Original post by Snagprophet

So where is this happening in Israel?

Seriously? Try following the thread.

Reply 4847

ThatPerson

Original post by leahmshaya

Firstly I'm not a survivor I am the descendant of one. And I don't see why it's disgraceful to explain why I feel a certain way about this.

Posted from TSR Mobile

It's an appeal to emotion and not founded in logic and reason. The fact that you are descended from a person who was in a concentration camp doesn't have any bearing on this issue we are discussing and bringing it up is a cheap shot at best.

Reply 4848

B2 Spirit

Original post by tsr1269

UK's arms export licenses, worth $13 billion, is under review.

Israel should review licences to the UK for their crimes in Iraq & Afghanistan.

Reply 4849

n00

Original post by leahmshaya

There was absolutely no mention of inadequate facilities

They would be living in tents for a start.

Original post by leahmshaya

or forced labour or mass execution.

a place in which large numbers of people, especially political prisoners or members of persecuted minorities, are deliberately imprisoned in a relatively small area with inadequate facilities, sometimes to provide forced labour or to await mass execution.

I believe he was also calling for the mass execution of any that refused to be imprisoned in these camps

(edited 9 years ago)

Reply 4850

Micah Richards

Original post by Snagprophet

She did though, she said she saw no evidence what the article claimed being linked to the facebook comments.

And then went on to play the 'offended' card.

So I told her what she did wrong.

This is a discussion, not a 'be sympathetic to me because of my bloodline' exchange.

Reply 4851

MASTER265

Original post by tsr1269

And therein has lay the problem of this conflict...

Do I also take that as admittance the solution you put forth was not "simple" and basically unpractical?

Reply 4852

B2 Spirit

palestinians increasing rocket fire during Israel's ceasefire.

Reply 4853

tsr1269

Original post by B2 Spirit

Israel should review licences to the UK for their crimes in Iraq & Afghanistan.

I don't disagree...

Reply 4854

MASTER265

Original post by tsr1269

UK's arms export licenses, worth $13 billion, is under review.

Lol the day the UK sacrifices money for civilians is the day pigs fly, we are even valuing our interests more when it comes to the sanctions against Russia.

Reply 4855

tsr1269

Original post by MASTER265

Do I also take that as admittance the solution you put forth was not "simple" and basically unpractical?

As practical as it was putting Israel into Arabia...

Reply 4856

tsr1269

Original post by B2 Spirit

palestinians increasing rocket fire during Israel's ceasefire.

There is no need for the Palestinians to observe the unilateral ceasefire...

Reply 4857

tsr1269

Original post by MASTER265

Lol the day the UK sacrifices money for civilians is the day pigs fly, we are even valuing our interests more when it comes to the sanctions against Russia.

As I have said, it is under review...

Reply 4858

leahmshaya

Okay, again the fact is that this language is particularly concerning to me because of my personal connection to the event that they are talking about. I'm not asking anyone to sympathise with me nor do I feel personally offended. I would guess and hope that the inflammatory nature of the mail's headline would also be of concern to others who can read a Facebook post and see the disparity, with or without a personal connection.

Posted from TSR Mobile

Reply 4859

tsr1269