What is your ideal weight for you? How does that compare to what a BMI ideal suggests? Do you agree with the BMI ideal?
I'm about 5"8 and my ideal weight tends to be about 9 and half stone, I fluctuate between 9 and 10 stone usually but with stress eating I'm currently about 10. I'd like to tone up a bit but I know I'm still within the ideal of BMI.I think the ideal according to BMI os higher than mine.
BMI isn't something you should base your ideal weight on. It's flawed in many ways.
I'd say, get to a position where you're aesthetically pleased with how you look. Then it doesn't matter what the scales or BMI says, does it?
BMI isn't something you should base your ideal weight on. It's flawed in many ways.
I'd say, get to a position where you're aesthetically pleased with how you look. Then it doesn't matter what the scales or BMI says, does it?
Agree totally with this, it doesn't take into account muscle which is heavier than fat, or your body structure - so as I say in the OP, often your ideal and BMI ideal don't match up
Agreed (although this person has maybe a condition going by what she responded idk) but:
Most people who have 'high metaboisms' eat like 3,000/ 3 1/2 thousand calories 2 days a week but then eat 1800 the rest. Something like that so what you end up with is maintenance or a small deficit despite 'eating loads' a few times a week.
If people tracked what they ate they'd be surprised.
I'm active when back home and i probably ate at a small surplus 4/5 days a week but super active 2/3 days a week and would end up with a decent deficit on those days. Hence why i was 60kg.
Agree totally with this, it doesn't take into account muscle which is heavier than fat, or your body structure - so as I say in the OP, often your ideal and BMI ideal don't match up
Although BMI doesn't work for all cases, they do tend to be the at the margins - pregnancy, very elderly, athletes or heavily muscled.
For most people, BMI is an good and fairly accurate way to establish an ideal weight.
I'm about 135-140lb (between 5'5 and 5'6) I'd love to get a lot heavier with muscle mass though I have like 3000 calories a day and I work out a lot - hopefully I'll grow. maybe not. my best friend is naturally hench as a hulk as only about an inch taller so I'm trying to get to that level
The weight I am now, the weight I was 2 years ago, and (hopefully) the weight I'll be in 2 years' time. Not to say I was never insecure about my weight lol. I used to think I was rly fat, and almost wanted to have anorexia, so that I'd be thin... Thank God that I didn't have the self-control to do something like that! Eventually, I just sort of figured that if my mum (who is rly slim) thought I was slim, I should probably just believe her and stop worrying about it!
That's quite a large gap... 10kg is like 1 1/2 stone. There's no way you fluctuate that much normally.
Oh no, I don't fluctuate between those two.. 95kg is the max I'd like to be and 85kg is the least. I'm current around 87kg after some heavy eating/exercise ... 2 years ago I was around 78kg.
Agreed (although this person has maybe a condition going by what she responded idk) but:
Most people who have 'high metaboisms' eat like 3,000/ 3 1/2 thousand calories 2 days a week but then eat 1800 the rest. Something like that so what you end up with is maintenance or a small deficit despite 'eating loads' a few times a week.
If people tracked what they ate they'd be surprised.
I'm active when back home and i probably ate at a small surplus 4/5 days a week but super active 2/3 days a week and would end up with a decent deficit on those days. Hence why i was 60kg.
My height is 5'8" and I weigh 8.66 stone(?) which is 55kg. Also, appaently my BMI is 18 which is great considering it always told me I was underweight loooool
Agreed (although this person has maybe a condition going by what she responded idk) but:
Most people who have 'high metaboisms' eat like 3,000/ 3 1/2 thousand calories 2 days a week but then eat 1800 the rest. Something like that so what you end up with is maintenance or a small deficit despite 'eating loads' a few times a week.
If people tracked what they ate they'd be surprised.
I'm active when back home and i probably ate at a small surplus 4/5 days a week but super active 2/3 days a week and would end up with a decent deficit on those days. Hence why i was 60kg.
This isn't rocket science
Well, I track what I eat pretty much every day. I'm sick of people trying to suggest I under eat when I don't. I've had my thyroid checked as the doctors thought I might have an overactive thyroid, but I don't. My body has to work harder than the average person in everyday things and so I burn more calories. I
Well, I track what I eat pretty much every day. I'm sick of people trying to suggest I under eat when I don't. I've had my thyroid checked as the doctors thought I might have an overactive thyroid, but I don't. My body has to work harder than the average person in everyday things and so I burn more calories. I
Well fair enough, you would be an exception. Eat more calories then.
I doubt you'd need as many calories as the average man.
Just find out what your maintenence is (not what the app is telling you) and then calorie count with your new BMR to get your TDEE