OK. So we can check those criteria in a few different ways. QS World University Rankings in large part base their tables on a surveys they send out to academic and employers around the world.
If we focus on
Academic Reputation alone (
link), then your four options are in this order:
•
City, University of London (74.9)• University of Birmingham (68.4)
• University of Leeds (64.9)
• Cardiff University (64.3)
If we instead focus on
Employer Reputation alone (
link) then the order changes:
•
University of Leeds (71.6)• University of Birmingham (70.2)
• Cardiff University (65.1)
• City, University of London (62.7)
Another measure we can use is graduate prospects - i.e. how past graduate got on in the workplace. The data below are from TheUniGuide, which uses data from Destinations of Leavers from Higher Education Survey and the Longitudinal Educational Outcomes dataset . They actually record data for Accounting separately to that for Finance, so I've averaged the numbers between the two (other than Birmingham for which Finance numbers aren't available):
The first three of the figures below are
six months after having graduated.
• Average annual salary: Cardiff: £21,000 |
City: £27,000 | Leeds: £21,250 | Birmingham: £24,000
• Employed or in further education: Cardiff: 94% | City: 92% |
Leeds: 99% | Birmingham: N/A
• Employed in a role where degree was essential or beneficial: Cardiff: 78.5% | City: 71.5% |
Leeds: 90% | Birmingham: 82%
• Median earnings of graduates five years ago: Cardiff: £39,000 |
City: £51,000 | Leeds: £42,000 | Birmingham: £37,000
Links to the above data:
•
Cardiff University•
City, University of London•
University of Leeds•
University of BirminghamI'm not sure whether the above is any help or not, given that it doesn't really present a very consistent picture.