The Student Room Group

Car hit my door as I opened it.

Hello
Could someone tell me what the best course of action would be in this situation?

I was parked on a single red line. The road was not busy. A car slammed into my open car door. It will cost around £1000 to repair my door, however his car has received minimal damage. Whose fault is it ?

I said I’d rather we each pay for the damage caused to our own cars. But they are insisting that it’s my fault only.

What should I do?

Reply 1

Original post by Sz199911
Hello
Could someone tell me what the best course of action would be in this situation?

I was parked on a single red line. The road was not busy. A car slammed into my open car door. It will cost around £1000 to repair my door, however his car has received minimal damage. Whose fault is it ?

I said I’d rather we each pay for the damage caused to our own cars. But they are insisting that it’s my fault only.

What should I do?

From your description it's entirely your fault.

Section 239 https://www.highwaycodeuk.co.uk/parking.html

Reply 2

Original post by Sz199911
Hello
Could someone tell me what the best course of action would be in this situation?

I was parked on a single red line. The road was not busy. A car slammed into my open car door. It will cost around £1000 to repair my door, however his car has received minimal damage. Whose fault is it ?

I said I’d rather we each pay for the damage caused to our own cars. But they are insisting that it’s my fault only.

What should I do?


It sounds like you might be at fault here. But the main thing is that you tell your car insurance provider. They may be able to cover the cost of some/most of the repair cost depending on what your excess is at.

Reply 3

Original post by Sz199911
Hello
Could someone tell me what the best course of action would be in this situation?

I was parked on a single red line. The road was not busy. A car slammed into my open car door. It will cost around £1000 to repair my door, however his car has received minimal damage. Whose fault is it ?

I said I’d rather we each pay for the damage caused to our own cars. But they are insisting that it’s my fault only.

What should I do?

This is different from you other post - was the car door open already or did it happen while you were opening the door?

Reply 4

Report it to your insurance company and let them work out liability. Don't try and haggle liability with the other driver esp as they are disputing (If I was involved in an accident and thought it was the other drivers fault, I wouldn't be too impressed at being told to pay for my own repairs)

Unless you could prove the other driver was speeding or using their phone or something I suspect it would be considered your fault.