The Student Room Group

Invest in Samsung's Ecosystem or Lenovo?

Hi
Im looking to be a tablet/laptop for uni, im doing engineering so I though its probably worth buying a min 8gb device with maybe 128gb/256gb storage and I found 2 amazing tablets,
1 is a Lenovo P12, and the other is a Samsung Tab S9 FE, both are similar tech wise, except the samsung is about 80-120 quid more, is that worth investing into the samsung ecosystem as I have a Samsung phone, watch and buds already, is that worth the extra 100 or should I give up the compatability,
Ps if I didn't have these, it would be no question I would choose the Lenonvo.
Tbh my experience with Lenovo over the years has been progressively worse. 10 years ago or so they did really high quality stuff at reasonable price points but over time the quality of the materials used and longevity of the machines as a result seemed to just get worse and worse. In the end I stopped buying their stuff.

128 or even 256 GB SSD is not really much "storage". For a laptop that's going to just about fit your OS plus a few bigger bits of software and not have too much space leftover very quickly. And you don't want to cram your SSD to max capacity as they run worse when there's less space. If it doesn't have a dual SSD/HDD setup with a 1 TB HDD as well or something you will definitely want to invest in an external HDD I think.

I don't think the "samsung ecosystem" is worth anything really. Also frankly I think you'd be wiser to invest in a proper laptop than just a tablet.
Reply 2
Original post by artful_lounger
Tbh my experience with Lenovo over the years has been progressively worse. 10 years ago or so they did really high quality stuff at reasonable price points but over time the quality of the materials used and longevity of the machines as a result seemed to just get worse and worse. In the end I stopped buying their stuff.

128 or even 256 GB SSD is not really much "storage". For a laptop that's going to just about fit your OS plus a few bigger bits of software and not have too much space leftover very quickly. And you don't want to cram your SSD to max capacity as they run worse when there's less space. If it doesn't have a dual SSD/HDD setup with a 1 TB HDD as well or something you will definitely want to invest in an external HDD I think.

I don't think the "samsung ecosystem" is worth anything really. Also frankly I think you'd be wiser to invest in a proper laptop than just a tablet.


I feel this might be a more of a revision tool/notes taking device because when I talked to a few uni students they told me most of the programs you run are on university computers that can handle this easily, what's your experience with it, if your ok to divulge
Original post by Singam21
I feel this might be a more of a revision tool/notes taking device because when I talked to a few uni students they told me most of the programs you run are on university computers that can handle this easily, what's your experience with it, if your ok to divulge

Yes specialist software will be om uni PC clusters. But a laptop is much more useful for typesetting things (e.g. lab reports).

I don't understand the reluctance of people to just write notes with a pen and paper now.
Reply 4
Original post by artful_lounger
Yes specialist software will be om uni PC clusters. But a laptop is much more useful for typesetting things (e.g. lab reports).

I don't understand the reluctance of people to just write notes with a pen and paper now.

It's the new generation way of doing things. My kids have got touchscreen graphics tablets to go along with their laptop. They make notes that are saved onto the cloud and their revision goes everywhere with them as accessible on the phone. Makes it easy to revise apparently. I can see some advantages but it's just getting used to a way of working.
Reply 5
Original post by artful_lounger

Yes specialist software will be om uni PC clusters. But a laptop is much more useful for typesetting things (e.g. lab reports).

I don't understand the reluctance of people to just write notes with a pen and paper now.


Well ive spent the last 2 yrs writing everything in pen and paper, whilst others in my class use ipads etc, and ive now have 5 huge binders worth of notes, ppqs, and required practical write ups, plus stuff on the laptop, whilst they carry around something that weighs one book with 2 yrs worth of notes neatly stored, like mines is easily organised but i can't carry everything, right. they also have saved a lot of printing. Im also looking to get preferably a 2 in1 so ill look to get a keyboard for the tablet for typing up something, sorry i didn't mention its a 2 in 1
Original post by Singam21
Well ive spent the last 2 yrs writing everything in pen and paper, whilst others in my class use ipads etc, and ive now have 5 huge binders worth of notes, ppqs, and required practical write ups, plus stuff on the laptop, whilst they carry around something that weighs one book with 2 yrs worth of notes neatly stored, like mines is easily organised but i can't carry everything, right. they also have saved a lot of printing. Im also looking to get preferably a 2 in1 so ill look to get a keyboard for the tablet for typing up something, sorry i didn't mention its a 2 in 1

You're not going to ohysically carry around notes for more than a single term at a time at most.

Not sure what the relevance of printing is as you'll either need to submit assignments digitally or physically- have not come across a situation where you have a choice of either. For some things like dissertations you need to submit both digitally and physically usually.

In any event my thoughts on lenovo are there. For 2 in 1 type devices ive generally heard positive things about MS surfaces.
Reply 7
Original post by artful_lounger

You're not going to ohysically carry around notes for more than a single term at a time at most.

Not sure what the relevance of printing is as you'll either need to submit assignments digitally or physically- have not come across a situation where you have a choice of either. For some things like dissertations you need to submit both digitally and physically usually.

In any event my thoughts on lenovo are there. For 2 in 1 type devices ive generally heard positive things about MS surfaces.


Alright thats great, thank you for your help
Original post by Singam21
Alright thats great, thank you for your help

The one caveat I would say about 2 in 1 devices is I have a friend with one and he's said after a couple of years, the screen/keyboard attachment has become a bit iffy and so sometimes the USB ports don't work properly and such. Which is quite frustrating apparently (I can imagine honestly as I use my USB ports all the time constantly...). So do keep in mind when you have more complexity in something like that, it means there are more possible failure points.

This is another reason I personally tend to stick to typical standard laptops rather than these modular 2 in 1/3 in 1/reverse upside down attachment type things :wink:

Honestly a regular laptop and pen and paper will get you through your course just fine. While yes you can get other things and do the same with them, it's not really an "improvement", just a different way of doing things - which as above, may have some downsides!

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending