The Student Room Group

Should I do Medicine? HELP!

I'm currently in year 12, studying Maths, Biology, Chemistry and French at A Level.
I love chemistry, as I find it so interesting, and I also like maths. I like some parts of biology (e.g. biochemistry, genetics, diseases), but I dislike other parts of it (e.g. exchange surfaces, body systems).
My career options are: GP (do a medicine degree), academic researcher (do a chem/biochem degree), chemical engineer, or pharmacy.

I have no idea if I should do medicine of pharmacy- I like the idea of helping people, but I'm quite shy (but I could get more confident). I also don't really like dissections, but I think that, after doing them more often, I would be able to get used to them.

I would do academic research, but the pay is quite low and it takes many years to get to a higher level. This is why chemical engineering/medicine/pharmacy sound more appealing (due to the higher pay).

Please help me decide what career I should do!
Hey there, thanks for posting a question in the Medicine forum. :biggrin:

The Medicine forum gets a high volume of questions being posted, and some of these are already answered by the resources and Megathreads that members of the community and volunteers have created. This is an automatic post which is designed to highlight these resources. Below is a list of threads and articles that could answer your question (you should be looking in the original post of the megathreads). If one of the below threads is a more relevant place to ask your question, please post a reply in that thread to ask your question. If your query is answered by one of the Megathreads or articles linked below, and you would like us to close this thread for you, please reply to this thread with just the words "thank you". A member of our team will then get it locked.

Megathreads
(Please read the first post, before then posting any further questions you have within that thread.)
The "Which Medical School Should I Apply To?" Uberthread
The Ultimate 'Am I Good Enough For Medicine?' Angst Thread
Medicine A-Level subjects queries
Work Experience and Voluntary Work

2023 Applicants:
Official Undergraduate Medicine 2023 Entry
Graduate Entry Medicine 2023 Entry
Medicine 2023 entry for resit / retake / gap year applicants
A100 Medicine for International Students 2023 Entry
Medicine Interview discussion 2023 Entry
2023 entry A100 / A101 Medicine fastest and slowest offer senders
Index of Individual Medical School Applicants' threads 2023 Entry

2024 Applicants :
Official Undergraduate Medicine 2024 Entry
Graduate Entry Medicine 2024 Entry
GAMSAT 2024 / 2025 entry discussions megathread
UCAT 2024 Entry Discussions Megathread

Other application years:
Graduate Entry Medicine 2025 Entry
Official Undergraduate Medicine 2025 Entry

Useful Articles:
GCSE Requirements for Medicine
Everything you need to know about the BMAT
Work Experience as a Graduate or Mature student
Medicine Personal Statement Advice
Medicine Personal Statement Advice (Graduate Entry)
Interview Frequently Asked Questions
MMI Medicine Interview Tips
What to do after an unsuccessful first application

If your query is answered by one of the Megathreads or articles linked above, and you would like us to close this thread for you, please reply to this thread with just the words "thank you". A member of our team will then get it locked.
Original post by KKS12345
I'm currently in year 12, studying Maths, Biology, Chemistry and French at A Level.
I love chemistry, as I find it so interesting, and I also like maths. I like some parts of biology (e.g. biochemistry, genetics, diseases), but I dislike other parts of it (e.g. exchange surfaces, body systems).
My career options are: GP (do a medicine degree), academic researcher (do a chem/biochem degree), chemical engineer, or pharmacy.

I have no idea if I should do medicine of pharmacy- I like the idea of helping people, but I'm quite shy (but I could get more confident). I also don't really like dissections, but I think that, after doing them more often, I would be able to get used to them.

I would do academic research, but the pay is quite low and it takes many years to get to a higher level. This is why chemical engineering/medicine/pharmacy sound more appealing (due to the higher pay).

Please help me decide what career I should do!

Have you tried getting some work experience in these fields? Think it might help.
If dissection is the main thing putting you off medicine, there are plenty of medical schools where you don't get involved with dissection. Agree with getting some work experience in the fields you are interested in to help you make up your mind (and have a read about the junior doctor strikes in England and the other issues facing junior doctors currently).
Reply 4
Original post by Tulipbloom
Have you tried getting some work experience in these fields? Think it might help.

I’ve tried, but there aren’t any places which are willing to give me work experience due to health and safety regulations
Reply 5
Original post by girl_in_black
If dissection is the main thing putting you off medicine, there are plenty of medical schools where you don't get involved with dissection. Agree with getting some work experience in the fields you are interested in to help you make up your mind (and have a read about the junior doctor strikes in England and the other issues facing junior doctors currently).

Are you a junior doctor? If you are, please can you give me details on the things you learn at med school and what you have to do on a daily basis?
Original post by KKS12345
Are you a junior doctor? If you are, please can you give me details on the things you learn at med school and what you have to do on a daily basis?


Things you learn at medical school:

Anatomy- the layout of the body in health. You need anatomy in virtually any line of practice because it is literally a road atlas and the foundation upon which other knowledge is built.
Physiology- how cells and body systems work in health. The body is made up of smaller systems operating in tandem with other smaller systems to form more complex systems that operate in unison as a complete organism. What affects system A may have effects on systems B and C.
Pathology/pathophysiology- disease processes and what occurs when they happen, right down to a cellular level if necessary.
Ethics in medicine- the application of human values to the science of medicine.
Sociology in medicine- seeing the patient through a prism that extends beyond a diagnosis.
Pharmacology- how medicines affect the body and how the body affects the medicines.
Clinical examinations- how to detect abnormalities or confirm normality, learning what a finding may mean.
Clinical data interpretation- knowing which test to order and what the results mean.
The body through out the full life course, through conception, embryo, birth and into old age and the last days of life.

What doctors do a lot of:

Speaking with patients and their families

Liaising with other colleagues or other professionals

Obtaining and analysing information

Ordering further methods of information collection (i.e. scans and tests)

Reviewing patients and their clinical condition or how they are doing

Performing practical procedures and surgeries on patients.

Documenting all of the above.

Continual revalidation and professional development through the entirety of their careers.

Conducting research.

Teaching others the art (and science) of medicine- I'm yet to meet a doctor who doesn't have a spark of enthusiasm when it comes to teaching others.


Hope this helps.

Note that not all schools use dissection as a learning tool. There are pros and cons of using dissection on courses. If you are very interested in anatomy there are intercalated degrees you can complete involving anatomy, physiology etc where you can expand on these particular skills.
(edited 1 year ago)
Reply 7
Original post by ErasistratusV
Things you learn at medical school:

Anatomy- the layout of the body in health. You need anatomy in virtually any line of practice because it is literally a road atlas and the foundation upon which other knowledge is built.
Physiology- how cells and body systems work in health. The body is made up of smaller systems operating in tandem with other smaller systems to form more complex systems that operate in unison as a complete organism. What affects system A may have effects on systems B and C.
Pathology/pathophysiology- disease processes and what occurs when they happen, right down to a cellular level if necessary.
Ethics in medicine- the application of human values to the science of medicine.
Sociology in medicine- seeing the patient through a prism that extends beyond a diagnosis.
Pharmacology- how medicines affect the body and how the body affects the medicines.
Clinical examinations- how to detect abnormalities or confirm normality, learning what a finding may mean.
Clinical data interpretation- knowing which test to order and what the results mean.
The body through out the full life course, through conception, embryo, birth and into old age and the last days of life.

What doctors do a lot of:

Speaking with patients and their families

Liaising with other colleagues or other professionals

Obtaining and analysing information

Ordering further methods of information collection (i.e. scans and tests)

Reviewing patients and their clinical condition or how they are doing

Performing practical procedures and surgeries on patients.

Documenting all of the above.

Continual revalidation and professional development through the entirety of their careers.

Conducting research.

Teaching others the art (and science) of medicine- I'm yet to meet a doctor who doesn't have a spark of enthusiasm when it comes to teaching others.


Hope this helps.

Note that not all schools use dissection as a learning tool. There are pros and cons of using dissection on courses. If you are very interested in anatomy there are intercalated degrees you can complete involving anatomy, physiology etc where you can expand on these particular skills.

This was very helpful, thank you!
If I’m not that interested in human anatomy, would you say that medicine is a bad choice?

Also, is there much chemistry or biochemistry content?
(edited 1 year ago)
Original post by KKS12345
This was very helpful, thank you!
If I’m not that interested in human anatomy, would you say that medicine is a bad choice?

Also, is there much chemistry or biochemistry content?


There is some biochemistry content- it is the foundation upon which a lot of physiology content is based. But it's not a biochemistry or biology degree. You will be taught some specific content that is integral to the medicine curriculum.

Not everyone enjoys anatomy- it is quite common for people to feel overwhelmed by the amount of content involved but I would say you will rely on at least some of your anatomy knowledge almost irrespective of what aspect of medicine you pursue in your career. But this all ok- not everyone enjoys every aspect of any course. You will have strengths and weaknesses and likes and dislikes- how you progress through the course will differ to the next person. That's ok.

I think the crux of medicine is this: do you enjoy working with people and interacting with them? Do you find people and their health interesting? Do you have the necessary degree of emotional intelligence to take the science of medicine and make it into an art?

Also, I think it is also very important to remember that medicine is a team game: you are constantly interacting with others in the pursuit of patient care. That being said, I have known people to dislike the feeling that they are constantly being scrutinised or that everyone in the room is 'watching' them. This isn't something everyone is automatically accustomed to, it can take a bit of time to become used to it. But doctors are leaders and often make a lot of decisions in the clinical team. As you become more experienced over time your leadership role will increase. A lot of learning activities in medical school are orientated around this goal and there will be times where the onus is on you to lead a team during a group activity or in group work.
(edited 1 year ago)
Reply 9
Original post by ErasistratusV
There is some biochemistry content- it is the foundation upon which a lot of physiology content is based. But it's not a biochemistry or biology degree. You will be taught some specific content that is integral to the medicine curriculum.

Not everyone enjoys anatomy- it is quite common for people to feel overwhelmed by the amount of content involved but I would say you will rely on at least some of your anatomy knowledge almost irrespective of what aspect of medicine you pursue in your career. But this all ok- not everyone enjoys every aspect of any course. You will have strengths and weaknesses and likes and dislikes- how you progress through the course will differ to the next person. That's ok.

I think the crux of medicine is this: do you enjoy working with people and interacting with them? Do you find people and their health interesting? Do you have the necessary degree of emotional intelligence to take the science of medicine and make it into an art?

Also, I think it is also very important to remember that medicine is a team game: you are constantly interacting with others in the pursuit of patient care. That being said, I have known people to dislike the feeling that they are constantly being scrutinised or that everyone in the room is 'watching' them. This isn't something everyone is automatically accustomed to, it can take a bit of time to become used to it. But doctors are leaders and often make a lot of decisions in the clinical team. As you become more experienced over time your leadership role will increase. A lot of learning activities in medical school are orientated around this goal and there will be times where the onus is on you to lead a team during a group activity or in group work.

ohh okay, thanks again for the reply!
i think i might find working with the public difficult, and i might not have a good work-life balance.

that being said, i think a chemistry or natural sciences degree is best for me! i can either go into research, finance, data science or industry- my options will be open!

thanks for the advice 🙂
Original post by KKS12345
ohh okay, thanks again for the reply!
i think i might find working with the public difficult, and i might not have a good work-life balance.

that being said, i think a chemistry or natural sciences degree is best for me! i can either go into research, finance, data science or industry- my options will be open!

thanks for the advice 🙂


I know several people who have completed University level studies and gone on to work in their respective fields, chemists, researchers, engineers and the like.

What I would advise all young people is that you should only go to study something at University if you are totally enthralled by it and enjoy it to the point that you would be satisfied working in the field in question for the bulk of your career. The people I have known make a success of these careers are very driven, highly motivated and often very gifted. It is an expensive and time consuming prospect these day which you don't want to get wrong.
Reply 11
Original post by ErasistratusV
I know several people who have completed University level studies and gone on to work in their respective fields, chemists, researchers, engineers and the like.

What I would advise all young people is that you should only go to study something at University if you are totally enthralled by it and enjoy it to the point that you would be satisfied working in the field in question for the bulk of your career. The people I have known make a success of these careers are very driven, highly motivated and often very gifted. It is an expensive and time consuming prospect these day which you don't want to get wrong.

the only thing that's holding me back is the salary of chemists and researchers...
but, i can always do patent law or go into finance as a backup!

do you know roughly how much the chemistry graduates you know earn? (ofc you don't have to tell me!!)

what degree did you do? (i'm assuming you did medicine?)
(edited 1 year ago)
Original post by KKS12345
the only thing that's holding me back is the salary of chemists and researchers...
but, i can always do patent law or go into finance as a backup!

do you know roughly how much the chemistry graduates you know earn? (ofc you don't have to tell me!!)

what degree did you do? (i'm assuming you did medicine?)


If you want to earn big money you have to pursue a career in something difficult to do, difficult to gain entry to or do something unusual or undesirable or with high levels of responsibility attached. You can earn big money in medicine if you enter private practice or pursue the more difficult/lucrative avenues. However these will not really be available to the average graduate until they accrue many years of practice and manage to pass the speciality exams.

You can of course earn excellent money if you pursue a career in things like plumbing/HVAC engineering, oil and gas exploration, mining or offshore work. Most of these involve being away from home for months at a time or working in some inhospitable places or doing work that is difficult and requires a lot of skill. An acquaintance of mine for example operates a tower crane at Hinkley C and earns in excess of £80K a year sitting down. Another is a train driver and earns £90K.
Reply 13
Original post by ErasistratusV
If you want to earn big money you have to pursue a career in something difficult to do, difficult to gain entry to or do something unusual or undesirable or with high levels of responsibility attached. You can earn big money in medicine if you enter private practice or pursue the more difficult/lucrative avenues. However these will not really be available to the average graduate until they accrue many years of practice and manage to pass the speciality exams.

You can of course earn excellent money if you pursue a career in things like plumbing/HVAC engineering, oil and gas exploration, mining or offshore work. Most of these involve being away from home for months at a time or working in some inhospitable places or doing work that is difficult and requires a lot of skill. An acquaintance of mine for example operates a tower crane at Hinkley C and earns in excess of £80K a year sitting down. Another is a train driver and earns £90K.

oh wow, thanks for the insight!

I think I’ll do chemistry- I can be a patent examiner or data scientist (after a masters in data science) after being a researcher for a few years (if I want to).
I don’t see any point in doing medicine if I don’t want to be a doctor at the end of it.
Original post by KKS12345
I'm currently in year 12, studying Maths, Biology, Chemistry and French at A Level.
I love chemistry, as I find it so interesting, and I also like maths. I like some parts of biology (e.g. biochemistry, genetics, diseases), but I dislike other parts of it (e.g. exchange surfaces, body systems).
My career options are: GP (do a medicine degree), academic researcher (do a chem/biochem degree), chemical engineer, or pharmacy.

I have no idea if I should do medicine of pharmacy- I like the idea of helping people, but I'm quite shy (but I could get more confident). I also don't really like dissections, but I think that, after doing them more often, I would be able to get used to them.

I would do academic research, but the pay is quite low and it takes many years to get to a higher level. This is why chemical engineering/medicine/pharmacy sound more appealing (due to the higher pay).

Please help me decide what career I should do!


What I would say is that it’s obviously up to you but my advice would be to do what you really enjoy (considering that pay level which seems quite important to you) and don’t force yourself into something you don’t like like dissection because (although you may become accustomed to it) you will spend most of your life doing these things day-in-day-out and it’s all about long term solutions and most importantly, the impact of your work on your mental health.
Original post by ErasistratusV
There is some biochemistry content- it is the foundation upon which a lot of physiology content is based. But it's not a biochemistry or biology degree. You will be taught some specific content that is integral to the medicine curriculum.
Not everyone enjoys anatomy- it is quite common for people to feel overwhelmed by the amount of content involved but I would say you will rely on at least some of your anatomy knowledge almost irrespective of what aspect of medicine you pursue in your career. But this all ok- not everyone enjoys every aspect of any course. You will have strengths and weaknesses and likes and dislikes- how you progress through the course will differ to the next person. That's ok.
I think the crux of medicine is this: do you enjoy working with people and interacting with them? Do you find people and their health interesting? Do you have the necessary degree of emotional intelligence to take the science of medicine and make it into an art?
Also, I think it is also very important to remember that medicine is a team game: you are constantly interacting with others in the pursuit of patient care. That being said, I have known people to dislike the feeling that they are constantly being scrutinised or that everyone in the room is 'watching' them. This isn't something everyone is automatically accustomed to, it can take a bit of time to become used to it. But doctors are leaders and often make a lot of decisions in the clinical team. As you become more experienced over time your leadership role will increase. A lot of learning activities in medical school are orientated around this goal and there will be times where the onus is on you to lead a team during a group activity or in group work.

Hi, I was wondering if you have any experience in the neurosurgery field? I'm in a similar position to the OP where I'm not sure whether medicine is the right career path for me. I do find it very meaningful to help patients get better both physically and mentally, but interacting with patients everyday is not something I think I would be good at. This is the main reason I've been wanting to become a neurosurgeon, because I do get to help patients while also immersing myself in neurology, which is a subject that I love learning about (although please correct me if I have an inaccurate perception of neurosurgery). On the other hand, I can't see myself working as a GP because I feel I would dread every day due to having to constantly communicate with patient after patient. To summarise, the prospect of working as a doctor (in terms of learning the biology of the human body, diseases etc) and the concept of helping people for me sounds very inviting, but having to speak with patients and their families doesn't. I'm not sure if I have an idealised perception of medicine or whether it is a career I truly want to pursue.

I think that communication is not something I'm naturally good at, and it's research based stuff and really analyzing science that I'm more interested in. I'm really conflicted because I don't want to go into a career that I might dread every day and I don't want to compromise patient care because of my lack of enthusiasm towards the job, but at the same time it feels like I'm too far gone into medicine that I can't really change my mind now.

Would you know anyone having a similar experience to this and whether they decided to continue medicine or change degrees?
Original post by seagull11
Hi, I was wondering if you have any experience in the neurosurgery field? I'm in a similar position to the OP where I'm not sure whether medicine is the right career path for me. I do find it very meaningful to help patients get better both physically and mentally, but interacting with patients everyday is not something I think I would be good at. This is the main reason I've been wanting to become a neurosurgeon, because I do get to help patients while also immersing myself in neurology, which is a subject that I love learning about (although please correct me if I have an inaccurate perception of neurosurgery). On the other hand, I can't see myself working as a GP because I feel I would dread every day due to having to constantly communicate with patient after patient. To summarise, the prospect of working as a doctor (in terms of learning the biology of the human body, diseases etc) and the concept of helping people for me sounds very inviting, but having to speak with patients and their families doesn't. I'm not sure if I have an idealised perception of medicine or whether it is a career I truly want to pursue.
I think that communication is not something I'm naturally good at, and it's research based stuff and really analyzing science that I'm more interested in. I'm really conflicted because I don't want to go into a career that I might dread every day and I don't want to compromise patient care because of my lack of enthusiasm towards the job, but at the same time it feels like I'm too far gone into medicine that I can't really change my mind now.
Would you know anyone having a similar experience to this and whether they decided to continue medicine or change degrees?

I'm afraid I have very little experience or knowledge of neurosurgery as a speciality. I do know it has an 8+ year speciality programme. This would mean it would take at least 10 years to complete training to consultant level in the UK after you graduated from medical school.

My colleague is similarly interested by neurosurgery as a speciality but recognised that competition ratios to obtain a training place in the UK is very steep, last I checked it was something like 15:1 and not all hospitals in the UK have neurology departments which would mean you will be geographically limited in where you might train and work.

If you were to pursue this as a career you would need to research it very carefully beforehand.

I also think that for people with the dream of working in a particular medical field should recognise that to reach that decision point you would need to learn a great deal about subjects that might not interest you in general, followed by at least 2 years of foundation training, although these days you may well need to be working as an F3, F4 or F5, if you don't get accepted for a training place the first time around. A lot of people enter medical school with the original dream of practicing in a particular speciality, but by the time they complete school, they have changed their minds, either because they found something they were very good at or which interested them more, or because their original idea didn't actually seem that great when they undertook placements within it.

Any surgical field will be quite intense because that is the nature of the business you will be in.

Feeling you are not great at communication is ok- many people entering medical school may not be that great at it either, but still having suboptimal communication skills when you leave medical school is not great and can lead to all kinds of grief. I have witnessed this kind of thing first hand. I would never say I was the best communicator either, but I have definitely seen examples of poor communication in practice. If you were to examine the number and nature of the majority of complaints made by patients to healthcare services, I strongly suspect that the root cause of many of them is due to failures in communication to patients.

And lastly, I have found that there is a common belief that general practice is an easier business and that it is easier because it has a shorter training pathway than other career paths. This myth is dispelled very early in medical school because general practice will be one of the first things any medical student is likely exposed to. General practice is actually one of the hardest specialities because of the nature of the work, the sheer number of undifferentiated patients and the complexity of any presenting case. It also has very real resource and time constraints.

In terms of your interest in research, you can work in research in neuroscience or similar by completing undergraduate and masters degrees in the relevant field. It is true that doctors working in clinical neurology may also work in research or even leave clinical practice completely to pursue a research career. You would need to weigh up what your ultimate goal is and seek advice on how to pursue that. Medical school teaches you and prepares you for a very specific end goal- to be able to work as a doctor and pursue additional training. Whilst this has obvious benefits for an individual is also has some non-negotiable requirements, notably you will have to learn about the entire human body and the entire realm of medicine. If your interest is in neuroscience and research, are you that sure you want to be learning about the skeleton, kidney and heart, dozens of differing medications and how to conduct consults with patients as part of this process?

Quick Reply